
The Ballad of Never After
Evangeline Fox is back in a partnership she had every reason to walk away from, because a curse has been set loose and the only way to break it runs through the Prince of Hearts.
About
Spoiler notice: Major spoilers for The Ballad of Never After, including its ending.
The story resumes in the Magnificent North after Evangeline Fox’s bargain with the Prince of Hearts has left Apollo in an enchanted sleep and her trust in Jacks badly damaged. In the royal library at Wolf Hall, she discovers that the sealed Valory Arch cannot be opened by her blood, as ordinary doors can. Four missing stones—luck, truth, mirth and youth—are its keys. Stories disagree about what lies beyond it: knowledge and treasure, or a dangerous force. Evangeline has reason to distrust Jacks, but she also wants Apollo restored and cannot ignore the arch’s connection to the North’s royal history. The North itself behaves like a story with rules that can obstruct plain speech: LaLa cannot freely explain what she knows, and the books Evangeline consults may shift while she reads.
The danger becomes immediate when Apollo wakes under a curse that turns him into the archer from the unfinished ballad Evangeline’s mother used to tell. He is compelled to hunt her, the fox, and the two are bound by a mirror curse that makes injuries to one appear on the other. Jacks insists that opening the arch could undo Apollo’s spell, though Evangeline cannot be certain he is telling her the whole truth. After Apollo wounds her with a poisoned arrow, Jacks takes her to Chaos, a vampire lord whose underground palace offers the venom needed to heal her. Chaos also wants the arch opened, hoping it will remove the helmet that conceals his face.
The search for the four stones turns into a trail through shifting histories and dangerous company. Evangeline first finds the luck stone in Chaos’s palace, then researches the old noble houses in his library, where books alter their titles and contents. A visit to Apollo’s imprisoned brother Tiberius warns her that the stones may be powerful enough to threaten the North. At LaLa’s engagement celebration in Slaughterwood Manor, Evangeline recovers the truth stone, which exposes a supposed ally’s deception. Petra, another key with the youth stone, attacks her; Evangeline kills her in self-defence. The encounter changes the quest from a puzzle about magical objects into a choice with a human cost. The objects do not simply unlock a door; each changes the pressure on the people who carry or seek it. Petra’s wig hides rose-gold hair like Evangeline’s, exposing the shared ability that makes both women useful to those pursuing the arch.
When someone tortures Apollo, the mirror curse inflicts the same wounds on Evangeline. Jacks carries her, injured and exhausted, to the Hollow, an inn on the ruined Merrywood estate where time has stopped. The refuge is full of old stories, strange clocks and traces of the children who once lived there. Its calm is complicated by the mirth stone, which can magnify the feelings a person wants to have. Evangeline gradually recognizes that the stone has been shaping her happiness with Jacks, and she removes it from the inn’s clock. The respite also brings clues about the Merrywood family and Jacks’s past: an old ballad, a childhood height mark, and names connected to the Valors begin to overlap with the present danger. Time’s stillness gives the Hollow a fairy-tale quality, but it also lets Evangeline and Jacks avoid the consequences waiting beyond its threshold. When the mirth stone is removed, the refuge loses its warmth, and their return to Chaos’s palace makes clear that the pause has ended.
The emotional mystery tightens alongside the stone hunt. Evangeline learns that LaLa’s curses on Apollo were meant to force the arch open, driven by her longing for the dragon imprisoned inside it. She also discovers that Jacks’s coldness hides a fear that his kiss will kill her, after he killed the first fox he loved. When the stones are brought together, Jacks explains that they can send someone back to a chosen moment. He wants to return to the day he met Donatella, hoping to change the course of his life and escape the danger he poses to Evangeline. She understands that his plan may erase their relationship, but he refuses to choose a future with her while he believes his curse makes her unsafe.
At the arch, Chaos is revealed as Castor Valor, the lost son whose family lies preserved beyond its doors. Reunited with them, he removes his helmet, but his vampire hunger overwhelms him; he drains Evangeline’s blood, and she dies before she can tell Jacks that she loves him. A chapter near the ending shifts away from Evangeline to the story curse that shapes the North. Jacks uses the stones to return to an earlier point, despite the Valors’ warning that time exacts another price. The opening of the arch then plays out again with altered choices: Jacks sends Evangeline away to protect her, Apollo emerges cured, and when Evangeline rejects him, he removes her memories of Jacks and himself. In the epilogue, Apollo presents himself to the bewildered Evangeline as her husband and protector, concealing his responsibility for what she cannot remember. The same doorway and choices recur, but Jacks’s warning pushes Evangeline away before she can join him, and Apollo’s intervention leaves her unable to remember the relationships that shaped her decisions. This volume ends with the cost of that altered sequence unresolved.
Book details
- Author
- Stephanie Garber
- Published
- 2022 (earliest confirmed edition)
- Series
- Once Upon a Broken Heart, book 2
- Subgenre
- Fairytale retelling, Fae and faerie
- Tags
- Romantasy
- Reading order
- Also on this shelf: Once Upon a Broken Heart (book 1), A Curse for True Love (book 3)
Review
Editor profile
Baby Bat
Goodreads and social links will be added soon.
- Goodreads — link coming soon
- Social media — link coming soon
