
A Curse for True Love
Evangeline appears to have got the ending she was promised: a husband, a castle in the Magnificent North and a story that everybody else recognises.
About
Spoiler notice: Major spoilers through the ending and epilogue, including the memory reveal, Jacks's history, and the final confrontation at the Tree of Souls.
A Curse for True Love closes Stephanie Garber's Once Upon a Broken Heart trilogy in the Magnificent North, a kingdom where old magic can bend stories, curses shape people's choices, and public reputation is something rulers can manufacture. Evangeline Fox wakes in a handsome castle with a prince who calls her his wife, but her memories of the year that brought her there are missing. Apollo says Jacks, the Prince of Hearts, stole them and tried to kill him. The story begins inside the fairytale ending Evangeline once wanted, then asks her to decide whether the life she has been handed is really hers. The novel assumes the earlier books' bargains and relationships, and its mysteries depend on knowing how Evangeline, Apollo, and Jacks reached this point.
The story moves among Evangeline, Apollo, and Jacks, with the epilogue briefly giving the story curse its own perspective. That shifting viewpoint lets the reader see how different the same apparent romance looks from inside and outside it. Evangeline has only Apollo's account, a scar shaped like a broken heart, and small reactions she cannot explain; meanwhile Apollo's chapters show that he did not die, and that he used magic from Aurora Valor to remove Evangeline's memories after learning she loved Jacks. He works to keep her close, directs the hunt for Jacks, and encourages reports that cast his rival as a monster. His protection increasingly looks like control, even as he tells himself he is rescuing Evangeline and the North.
Evangeline's doubts gather through concrete interruptions to castle life. A tutor's enchanted book keeps changing the tale it tells about her past, while servants hesitate when she asks about Apollo. After she is lured to a wishing well and rescued by a stranger she knows as Archer, physical closeness brings back fragments. At a royal banquet, a toast to true love and a curse on its enemies unsettles her; she has already seen Apollo's anger and learned that guards were killed after failing to keep her safe. The supposed fairytale becomes harder to accept when she discovers that Jacks has been entering the castle, saves her from an assassin, and seems familiar in a way she cannot put into words. His chapters add what she cannot yet know: he loves her, but believes she is safer without him.
The Hunt carries Evangeline into the Cursed Forest, where the landscape turns into places from her past and offers memories without letting her hold them. A noble tries to kill her over an event she cannot remember, and Jacks reaches her in the forest. Its magic recreates the Hollow before they leave for a nearby inn. At that inn, she finds a note inside Jacks’s doublet that she wrote to herself, warning that Jacks once poisoned Apollo and used her as a key to open the Valory Arch. Reading it brings her memories back, including her own love for Jacks, the harm he caused, and Apollo's part in erasing her past. The recovered history does not make either man's actions simple: Jacks made choices that endangered her, while Apollo deliberately took away her ability to choose at all.
The Valors' return draws the older curses into the present. Aurora, who helped Apollo alter Evangeline's memory, has her own history with Jacks and wants him for herself. Evangeline and LaLa search Aurora's hidden rooms and find evidence that Aurora placed the Archer's curse on Jacks, forcing him to kill the girl he loved. Evangeline suspects Aurora also caused the lethal danger surrounding Jacks's kisses; LaLa agrees that Aurora is a likely culprit. Aurora later claims that anyone able to love Jacks will die from his kiss, trying to turn Evangeline’s resolve into fear. Jacks's attempt to protect Evangeline takes a terrible form: he traded away his loving heart for the Slaughterwood Cuff, which warns and hurts anyone about to harm its wearer. He thinks removing his heart will keep him from hurting her.
Evangeline follows Jacks to a Phoenix Tree, where his heart is held apart from him, and refuses to let his fear make the decision for them. She kisses him; the jar breaks, his heart returns, and she survives the moment she thought might kill her. Jacks had stolen his heart back from Aurora and intended to burn it rather than risk loving Evangeline. Her survival prevents that destruction and lets them acknowledge their love. Their reunion is interrupted when Apollo takes Evangeline to the Tree of Souls, hoping to drink its blood and gain immortality. The Valors explain that the tree takes the drinker's most loved person. Apollo drinks expecting Evangeline to pay the price, but the tree consumes him: the person he loves most is himself. His face joins the others in its trunk. Evangeline escapes the struggle and chooses Jacks over the throne and title that once looked like her happy ending.
The ending gives the couple a moment together but does not pretend that love erases the North's history or resolves every danger. In the epilogue, the story curse watches Evangeline and Jacks leave the Tree of Souls and then turns away as they kiss, closing their tale while leaving other characters' stories open. Garber's close access to Evangeline makes uncertainty part of the plot: readers encounter missing facts as she does, then see them reframed by Apollo's and Jacks's chapters. The contrast between public stories, private memories, and magical versions of events carries the conclusion. The Valors depart to reclaim their castle, while Evangeline gives up the royal future she had mistaken for her own choice.
Book details
- Author
- Stephanie Garber
- Published
- 2023 (earliest confirmed edition)
- Series
- Once Upon a Broken Heart, book 3
- Subgenre
- Fairytale retelling, Fae and faerie
- Tags
- Romantasy
- Reading order
- Also on this shelf: Once Upon a Broken Heart (book 1), The Ballad of Never After (book 2)
Review
Editor profile
Baby Bat
Goodreads and social links will be added soon.
- Goodreads — link coming soon
- Social media — link coming soon
