
Once Upon a Broken Heart
Evangeline Fox has believed in true love and happy endings for as long as she can remember, right up until the person she loves announces he is marrying someone else.
About
Spoiler notice: Spoilers for the full first volume, including the wedding, Apollo's apparent death, the murder investigation, the prophecy, and the final reveal.
Stephanie Garber places this first Once Upon a Broken Heart novel between a southern country where magic is treated as rumor and the Magnificent North, where stories, bargains, and old enchantments shape daily life. Evangeline Fox grew up around her father's magic shop and her mother's tales of the North, so when the hidden church of the Prince of Hearts disappears, she searches for its door instead of dismissing the event. A broken-heart prayer brings her face to face with Jacks, one of the immortal Fates. Their meeting turns a private heartbreak into a contract whose cost keeps resurfacing as Evangeline travels farther from home.
Evangeline's first crisis is Luc Navarro's decision to marry her stepsister, Marisol. Convinced that a curse has turned Luc away from her, she asks Jacks to stop the wedding. He agrees in exchange for three kisses, given to people and at times he will choose. Evangeline accepts because she is desperate to keep the future she imagined with Luc, and Jacks marks the bargain on her wrist. The wedding is stopped in a way she never intended: the guests are turned to stone. To free them, Evangeline drinks the poison that will make her take their place, remaining a statue for six weeks. Her sacrifice becomes public legend, while the truth of her bargain stays private.
When Evangeline returns to life, she finds Luc gone and her father's shop sold. The evidence gradually changes what she thinks happened between Luc and Marisol, and she has to live with having acted on a fear she could not prove. An invitation from Empress Scarlett offers a route north: attend Nocte Neverending, a magical ball where Prince Apollo will choose a bride. Evangeline brings Marisol with her, partly to give her stepsister a chance beyond the reputation of a cursed bride. Their journey brings the bargain back into reach, as Jacks reappears and the three promised kisses become entangled with the palace's courtship, gossip, and magic.
The North seems to offer the happy ending Evangeline has been waiting for. Nocte Neverending turns a gathering into a landscape of enchanted doors, games, and shifting possibilities, and Apollo's public proposal makes her feel wanted. His attention soon grows too intense to trust. Evangeline suspects that Jacks has altered Apollo's feelings, and their investigation leads through royal rooms, gossip sheets, and the vaults of House Fortuna. An ancient arch responds to Evangeline and a prophecy links her marriage to Apollo with the Valory Arch. Jacks needs her to open it, but refuses to tell her what lies behind the prophecy or what the arch contains. The court's romantic spectacle now sits beside a mystery about the North's former royal family and the doors that conceal its history.
Evangeline still chooses to marry Apollo, hoping Jacks will undo the spell and leave the prince with feelings of his own. The wedding does not settle anything: after the kiss intended to break the enchantment, Apollo collapses and appears dead, and Evangeline is arrested. Jacks gets her out, but poison derived from the tears of LaLa, the Unwed Bride, threatens to make Evangeline cry herself to death. LaLa supplies the antidote that saves her. The danger turns into an investigation. Evangeline and Jacks seek information from Chaos, a vampire Fate whose realm is built around spies, assassins, and dangerous bargains. There they find Luc among the people being transformed into vampires; his account of Marisol complicates Evangeline's memories of their shared past, while his bite infects Jacks and forces the group to escape.
The search for Apollo's killer draws Evangeline into Jacks's hidden library, where old storybooks and a disguised spell book connect the love spells around her to Marisol. Evangeline brews a truth potion and uses it to confront Prince Tiberius. He reveals that he belonged to a group trying to keep the Valory Arch closed, and the prophecy says Evangeline's blood must be given willingly to open it. Tiberius confesses that he caused Apollo's apparent death. A girl with the ability to read the secrets of the dead cannot read Apollo's, revealing that he is alive but suspended. Evangeline's attempt to wake him fails, and she concludes that Jacks has shaped the tragedies to get her willing blood for the arch. She resolves to open another door and pursue the hidden history without accepting Jacks's plan.
The story keeps close to Evangeline's understanding, allowing familiar fairy-tale promises to become clues and traps as new information changes what earlier events seemed to mean. Short pieces from the Whisper Gazette and the Daily Rumor interrupt the continuous narrative with public versions of private events, often spreading speculation before Evangeline knows the facts. This volume ends with Apollo's condition unresolved, Evangeline set against Jacks's purpose, and a mysterious door in the palace stirring behind its wolf's-head emblem. Evangeline has regained her status as a princess after Tiberius’s confession, but that restoration leaves her husband unconscious and her hoped-for marriage suspended with him. Her immediate purpose becomes finding answers for herself while keeping her willing blood beyond Jacks’s reach.
Book details
- Author
- Stephanie Garber
- Published
- 2021 (earliest confirmed edition)
- Series
- Once Upon a Broken Heart, book 1
- Subgenre
- Fairytale retelling, Fae and faerie
- Tags
- Romantasy
- Reading order
- Also on this shelf: The Ballad of Never After (book 2), A Curse for True Love (book 3)
Review
Editor profile
Baby Bat
Goodreads and social links will be added soon.
- Goodreads — link coming soon
- Social media — link coming soon
