V4mp

Explore V4mp

Baby Bat’s library

Find your next route. Get back to playing.

BookLiterary Fiction
← Back to the literary fiction shelf
Cover of These Twain by Arnold Bennett

These Twain

Arnold Bennett1915Literary fictionModern classics

Edwin Clayhanger has married Hilda and established himself as a prosperous printer in the Five Towns.

About

Spoiler notice: This overview discusses the Dartmoor prison visit, Auntie Hamps's death and estate, and Edwin's decision about the country house at the ending.

These Twain takes up Edwin and Hilda Clayhanger's story after the achievement that many novels would use as an ending: they are married. In 1892, Edwin has a successful printing business and a carefully maintained house in Bleakridge, the residential suburb of Bursley. Neither provides the settled contentment their owner might reasonably expect. Arnold Bennett begins with the suburb itself, where old terraces and ambitious newer houses carry different claims to respectability. Addresses, building materials and small improvements express judgments about who belongs. Edwin's home has its own accumulated history, including memories of his father that redecoration cannot remove. Into this familiar territory comes a wife with strong preferences of her own. The third Clayhanger novel follows the continuing adjustments that their union requires.

Edwin's pleasure in his house is remarkably specific. Fresh mortar, properly fitted drainpipes, a newly installed radiator and pictures chosen with growing artistic confidence all contribute to his sense of having made a life. Bennett treats these attachments as both comic and serious. Edwin can recognize something ridiculous in himself without ceasing to care about it. Hilda does not enter an empty space waiting for her personality; she enters a place already organized around his habits and memories. Her choices about rooms and household arrangements therefore carry a significance beyond convenience. Each believes that particular wishes ought to be understood by the other, and each discovers limits to that understanding. The domestic setting gives disagreements a physical form, locating them in rooms that both must continue to inhabit.

Hilda's son George adds another relationship to the household. He develops a friendship with Edwin, whom he calls uncle, and brings interests and expectations that cannot simply be fitted into a husband's idea of married life. Servants, relatives and visitors also make the home a social institution. An evening of music requires arrangements, work and decisions about how people should be accommodated; its pleasant surface depends upon somebody managing the details. Hilda's earlier boarding-house experience belongs to the practical knowledge she brings with her. Edwin can appreciate her abilities while resisting the demands associated with them. Bennett builds the marriage through such overlapping responsibilities, showing how a private disagreement may be intensified by the presence of people who have their own claims upon the couple.

The printing works provide Edwin with another centre of attention, and a place where his competence seems less disputable. Yet the business is also subject to judgments he cannot control. When the inspector Ingpen visits the lithography room, Edwin's pride in having supplied abundant light meets a practical objection: the glass roof has helped make the room excessively hot. The question of ventilation redirects attention from the employer's intentions to the conditions experienced by workers. Edwin begins defensively, then finds himself respecting the seriousness of Ingpen's duties. The scene gives the industrial world its own substance, with machinery, technical processes, noise and bodily discomfort. It also establishes a pattern familiar from the marriage: a provision that seems generous to its maker may look rather different to somebody living with its effects.

The past remains present in a more painful form during the visit to Dartmoor prison. Hilda recognizes George Cannon among the convicts, and the encounter cannot be reduced to a safe account of events preceding her marriage. The visitors' tour, with its locked gates, cells and official explanations, turns confinement into something they can inspect before returning to ordinary social life. Hilda experiences it through a particular person and the memory of their intimacy. Her conviction of Cannon's innocence belongs to her response; the scene's emotional force does not require the reader to accept every judgment she makes. Edwin's discomfort with the institution supplies another perspective. The episode lets the couple share a situation while showing how different their inward experiences of that situation remain.

Later pressures include Auntie Hamps's decline, death and estate, which connect family feeling to property and obligation. Hilda's wish to leave Bursley for Ladderedge Hall becomes a concentrated point of conflict. Edwin hears a demand that threatens the arrangements of his life; Hilda sees a chance to loosen the business's hold upon him. In speaking to Janet, she describes a husband considerate in many small matters but continually governed by the works. Her desired move is consequently more than a preference for a different address. It concerns whose priorities will determine their shared future. Their Christmas dispute brings that question to a crisis, and Edwin's walk away from home gives him space to consider whether continuing resistance is really the victory he imagines it to be.

On a canal bridge, Edwin decides to yield. He still regards Hilda's demands as unjust, but recognizes that a marriage cannot depend upon receiving perfect fairness before making an accommodation. His discovery includes an awkwardly revealing confidence in his own reasonableness: accepting another person's faults proves easier than identifying his own. Bennett does not promise that the insight will end their quarrels. At the later gathering, affection is openly expressed and the sale of the old house has moved their plans forward, while Edwin remains aware of what he is leaving. George is growing up, friends bring further histories into the room, and the marriage continues within that moving world. The novel ends with renewed closeness rather than an account of a permanently solved relationship.

Book details

Author
Arnold Bennett
First published
1915
Series
Clayhanger Trilogy, book 3
Subgenre
Literary fiction, Modern classics
Primary genre
Literary Fiction
Tags
No tags for this book.
Reading order
Also on this shelf: Clayhanger (book 1), Hilda Lessways (book 2)

Review

Review coming soon

Editor profile

Books editor

Baby Bat

Goodreads and social links will be added soon.

  • Goodreads — link coming soon
  • Social media — link coming soon