V4mp

Explore V4mp

Find your next route. Get back to playing.

← Back to the film shelf
To Have and Have Not poster
V4mp Cinema

To Have and Have Not

1944 · Howard Hawks

Fishing-boat skipper Harry Morgan tries to stay out of wartime politics in Martinique. An unpaid charter, a stranded American woman and a job carrying resistance passengers draw him into danger. As his relationship with Slim develops, Harry must choose how far he will go to protect the people around him.

RomanceDramaWarAdventure

Behind the film

Year
1944
Director
Howard Hawks
Writers
Jules Furthman, William Faulkner, Ernest Hemingway
Genres
Romance, Drama, War, Adventure
Production
Warner Bros. Entertainment
Country
United States
Cast
Humphrey Bogart, Walter Brennan, Lauren Bacall, Dolores Moran, Hoagy Carmichael, Marcel Dalio, Sheldon Leonard, Dan Seymour

About the film

Contains story spoilers, including the ending.

To Have and Have Not places Harry Morgan's fishing boat in Martinique during the summer of 1940, after the fall of France. Humphrey Bogart plays the American skipper who wants to earn his living without becoming involved in the island's political struggle. Lauren Bacall makes her film debut as Marie Browning, whom Harry calls Slim. Walter Brennan plays Eddie, Harry's drinking companion and crewman. Howard Hawks directs, with Jules Furthman and William Faulkner credited for the screenplay, adapted from Ernest Hemingway's novel.

Harry's refusal to help the resistance is tested by a charter customer who will not settle his bill. Johnson claims he needs to wait for the banks to open, but Slim steals his wallet and Harry discovers that the money is there in traveller's cheques. Before he can collect what he is owed, gunfire outside the hotel kills Johnson. Questioning by the authorities leaves Harry with less money and fewer ways to stay independent. Frenchy, the hotel owner, offers him a paid job transporting Paul de Bursac and his wife, Helene, for the resistance. Harry accepts, and the trip brings a patrol boat's gunfire and a wounded passenger. He has also bought Slim a ticket home, but returns to find she has chosen to stay. The practical problem of getting paid has drawn him into a rescue and tied his plans to a woman who could have left him behind.

Harry removes the bullet from Paul's shoulder and learns that the de Bursacs intend to help a man escape from Devil's Island. He initially refuses further involvement. The police then reveal that they have detained Eddie and can force him to talk about the boat's passengers. Harry turns the confrontation around at gunpoint, compelling them to release Eddie and sign the passes he needs to leave the harbour. He agrees to take the de Bursacs on the next stage of their mission. Harry, Slim and Eddie leave together. Their departure joins the romance to a decision Harry has resisted throughout the story: accepting a responsibility beyond keeping his own boat working. The prison escape remains a plan ahead of them, rather than an operation completed within the film's ending.

Slim meets Harry on his own terms. Their hotel-room exchanges move from requests for a match to kisses and invitations whose meaning neither needs explained. She calls him Steve, answering the nickname he has given her. Downstairs, music gives her another place in the hotel, with Hoagy Carmichael as the pianist Cricket. Bacall later described Hawks's ideal heroine as someone who could look a man in the eye, answer back and keep a sense of humour. Slim's assurance fits that description while Harry is still trying to decide whom he can trust.

Bacall's confidence on screen came with considerable nerves during filming. She told Terry Gross that her head and hands shook when Hawks called for action. Lowering her chin and looking up helped keep her head steady, producing the expression later called 'The Look'. Hawks also wanted her voice to stay low during anger or excitement, when it might naturally rise. Bacall remembered Bogart making their scenes easier because he wanted her to do well. She said that their attraction also affected the developing romance: after seeing their scenes in the rushes, Bogart felt audiences would never believe Harry abandoning Slim for another woman. Singing remained her own work too. Bacall explained that Andy Williams recorded a backup for 'How Little We Know' because Hawks worried about her high notes, but that his recording was not used in the film.

The whistle scene began before the feature itself. Hawks recalled writing it for Bacall's screen test and then struggling to find a place for it in the screenplay because the test had gone so well. He credited Faulkner with suggesting the hotel corridor, where the two characters could be alone, and with writing the material leading into the exchange. Hawks claimed the whistle line itself. His account makes the scene a piece of writing shaped around Bacall's test performance, with its setting found afterward, rather than an improvised exchange that happened to survive filming.

Hawks had brought Bacall to Hollywood after his wife noticed her photograph on the cover of Harper's Bazaar. Hawks paid close attention to the makeup, lighting and photography of Bacall's screen test, giving the newcomer a carefully prepared introduction to the camera. Once shooting began, Bogart helped her feel comfortable among the experienced cast, reducing the pressure of playing her first leading role. The novel underwent a change of surroundings as well. Hemingway had placed his story in Cuba. The U.S. Office of the Coordinator of Inter-American Affairs objected to that setting because it feared a strain on Cuban-American relations. Martinique became the film's setting. The move gave Harry's work and his reluctance to help Frenchy a different wartime situation, with resistance passengers and Vichy authorities competing for control of his boat's movements.

Keep exploring

Meet the editors

Two seats. Two perspectives.

V4mp and Baby Bat.
A shared love of stories, with room for different takes.

V
V4mpFILMS & GAMES

One half of Dead Good Reviews.

B
Baby BatFILMS, BOOKS & GAMES

The curator behind Baby Bat’s Library.