Behind the film
- Year
- 1969
- Director
- Sydney Pollack
- Writers
- James Poe, Horace McCoy, Robert E. Thompson
- Runtime
- 1h 59m
- Genres
- Drama, Historical drama, Psychological thriller
- Production
- American Broadcasting Company
- Country
- United States
- Cast
- Jane Fonda, Michael Sarrazin, Gig Young, Susannah York, Red Buttons, Bonnie Bedelia, Bruce Dern, Al Lewis
About the film
Contains story spoilers, including the ending.
They Shoot Horses, Don't They? places Robert Syverton's account of a dance marathon inside the circumstances of his later punishment. Sydney Pollack's 1969 drama follows the Depression-era competition through Robert and Gloria Beatty, played by Michael Sarrazin and Jane Fonda. Robert enters the Aragon Ballroom as a spectator, then becomes Gloria's replacement partner after her first partner is disqualified. The contestants include Alice, an aspiring actress, and James and his pregnant wife Ruby. Rocky presides over people whose poverty makes a prolonged ordeal seem worth attempting. Robert's memory of an injured horse's destruction belongs to the film's framing of the tragedy, while the ballroom action follows the changing partnerships and physical attrition of the contest. His later fate therefore hangs over the dancing before the competition's final consequences become clear. The two time frames make survival on the floor only one part of what is at stake.
Rocky uses the dancers' vulnerabilities to keep the spectators interested. The disappearance of Alice's dress creates suspicion, and partnerships change as Gloria reacts to Robert's attention to Alice. Gloria later dances with Sailor, whose heart fails during a derby. She carries him across the finish, but cannot save him. Alice's distress eventually takes her out of the competition, leaving Robert and Gloria together again. Rocky proposes a public marriage to attract support, then admits that expenses will eat into the prize. Winning would not deliver the escape Gloria has been enduring the marathon to obtain. The pair leaves, and outside Gloria asks Robert to shoot her when she cannot pull the trigger herself. He does so and is arrested, explaining himself through the comparison with putting down a horse. The marathon continues without them. The dancers' removal does not stop the entertainment, and Robert's attempt to answer Gloria's request brings its own fatal consequence for him. Leaving the ballroom ends their participation, but it does not restore the possibilities they had hoped the prize might buy.
Pollack chose widescreen because he wanted the people around a conversation to remain visible. The studio questioned that decision for a film largely confined to one set, but he wanted the dancers, spectators and band to stay in the image even when he was close to two characters. Their private exchanges therefore happen inside a working spectacle, with other bodies and watching faces nearby. The width could keep the event present without requiring every shot to pull away from the actors. Pollack also put on roller skates to film the marathon, following performers with a camera. His account of operating equipment makes clear that he could take an additional camera when a scene called for it, while leaving the principal operating role to the camera crew. In this film, following the dancers and keeping their surroundings in view offered different ways to retain the pressure of the room.
Fonda's work on Gloria involved more than sustaining a tired appearance. Pollack invited her ideas about the story's underlying concerns, an approach she found surprising after her earlier roles. She and Red Buttons tried dancing to exhaustion to learn something of the subject physically. Fonda later recalled hallucinating after two days, a much shorter trial than the ordeal the characters undergo. That account belongs to her preparation, rather than describing a medical condition assigned to Gloria. Gig Young also faced a departure from the romantic comedies associated with him when he took on Rocky. The master of ceremonies needs to sell the event smoothly while knowing how it uses its entrants. Young received the supporting-actor Academy Award for the role. Together, those performance demands place a worn-down contestant opposite the man who must keep presenting exhaustion as a reason for people to watch and pay. Rocky's command of the room depends on finding a new attraction as the dancers become less able to provide one.
Pollack joined the project shortly before shooting. In an interview with Bertrand Tavernier and Max Tessier, he recalled being approached six weeks ahead of production after James Poe and the producers parted company. He brought in Robert Thompson and reworked the script, including its characters and final sequences. In another conversation, Pollack explained that a film set in the past could still take its point of view from the present. He wanted historical detail without giving up the freedom to make a story relevant to contemporary life.
The ballroom's sound and display keep announcing pleasure while the dancers' bodies fail. A trio plays 'Brother, Can You Spare a Dime?' beneath the spinning chandelier, and Rocky maintains his patter. Ruby's performance of 'The Best Things in Life Are Free' meets an audience throwing pennies. Music remains a working part of the contest even as the room becomes harder to endure. Slow motion and flash-forwards interrupt that public rhythm, separating the spectacle's continuing motion from the punishment already waiting beyond it.

