Behind the film
- Year
- 1998
- Director
- Peter Farrelly, Bobby Farrelly
- Writers
- Ed Decter, John J. Strauss, Peter Farrelly, Bobby Farrelly
- Runtime
- 1h 54m
- Genres
- Romantic comedy
- Production
- 20th Century Studios
- Country
- United States
- Cast
- Cameron Diaz, Matt Dillon, Ben Stiller, Lee Evans, Chris Elliott, Jeffrey Tambor, Keith David, Sarah Silverman
About the film
Contains story spoilers.
The story begins in Cumberland, Rhode Island, in 1985, with Ted Stroehmann trying to turn a crush into a real date. He has spent high school admiring Mary Jensen from a distance, but when he protects her brother Warren from bullies, Mary notices him and asks him to the prom. Ted reaches her house, nerves take over, and a bathroom mishap sends him to hospital before the evening can begin. Mary moves away soon afterwards, leaving Ted with a short, embarrassing memory that he has managed to stretch across thirteen years. By 1998 he is a magazine writer, still single and still imagining the life he might have had with her.
Ted’s friend Dom points him toward Pat Healy, a private investigator who is supposed to locate Mary. Pat finds her in Miami, where she works as an orthopedic surgeon and lives near Warren. Pat tells Ted that Mary has become unattractive and has children with several different men, hoping to remove his competition. Then he moves to Miami himself, watches Mary, and uses what he learns to present himself as the man she wants.
Ted eventually learns that Pat lied and decides to travel south anyway. His trip becomes a detour through a police station after an escaped serial killer leaves a body in Ted’s car; officers arrest Ted before the hitchhiker is identified as the culprit. Dom sees the arrest on television, comes to bail him out and drives him the rest of the way. In Miami, Ted finds Mary under the surname Matthews, a change she made to avoid a stalker. He asks her to dinner and, at first, the two of them get along.
Another suitor is Tucker, who presents himself as a British architect and becomes one of Mary’s patients. Tucker first drives Mary away from Pat by showing her fabricated police records that portray the investigator as a murderer. Pat follows him and discovers the truth: Tucker is Norm, a pizza delivery man who injured his own back to get close to Mary and has kept pretending to need crutches after he healed. He and Pat dislike each other, but both are trying to keep Mary from choosing Ted. Their rivalry produces the film’s escalating chain of staged evidence, false identities and sabotage. They even drug the dog belonging to Mary’s neighbour Magda, hoping to discredit Ted during his dates. For a while, the tricks work as slapstick complications around an ordinary romance; then an anonymous letter exposes Ted’s role in hiring Pat, and Mary ends the relationship.
Ted confronts Pat, who denies writing the letter. Dom then appears at Mary’s apartment and admits he sent it. Mary recognises him as Woogie, the ex-boyfriend she had to escape with a restraining order. The identity explains why she changed her name and moved: the men around her have not merely been awkward admirers. They have followed her, lied to her and tried to make decisions on her behalf. Norm and Pat are listening outside when Dom attempts to steal Mary’s shoes, and they rush in. Ted arrives with Brett Favre, another former boyfriend whose relationship with Mary was sabotaged by Norm’s lies. The room gathers nearly every version of the same fantasy: that Mary’s affection can be won by outmaneuvering the other men.
Ted finally recognises how his own pursuit fits the pattern. Hiring a stranger to watch Mary has crossed a boundary, even if he has told himself that his intentions are romantic. That recognition makes his decision to leave different from another defeat in the contest for her attention. He tells Mary he is no better than Pat, Norm or Dom, and says she should be with Brett. For once he steps out of the competition rather than trying to secure the ending he has rehearsed since high school. Mary follows him and says she would be happiest with him. Their choice of each other interrupts the cycle of lies, although the film sends one more suitor into the scene: Magda’s boyfriend, who admits he used Magda to get near Mary and fires a rifle at Ted. He misses Ted and hits Jonathan, the singing narrator who has accompanied the story.
Ted’s disastrous prom-night accident and later date-night embarrassment are built as physical comic shocks, but the misunderstandings keep moving the relationship forward. Pat’s false report sends Ted away; his renewed trip brings him into Mary’s present; Dom’s confession reveals how seriously she has had to protect herself; and Ted’s retreat gives Mary room to choose. Cameron Diaz’s Mary is not simply the prize at the end of a race. She is a working surgeon with a life in Miami and a complicated history with Warren, Magda and the men who keep turning up. The film’s final joke lands because it has already made that distinction clear.

