Behind the film
- Year
- 2009
- Director
- Michael Haneke
- Writers
- Michael Haneke
- Runtime
- 2h 24m
- Genres
- Drama, Historical, Mystery
- Production
- Les Films du Losange
- Country
- France, Germany, Austria, Italy
- Cast
- Ulrich Tukur, Josef Bierbichler, Susanne Lothar, Ursina Lardi, Janina Fautz, Christian Friedel, Ernst Jacobi, Leonie Benesch
About the film
Contains story spoilers.
The story is told by an elderly man looking back to the summer of 1913, when he was a young schoolteacher in Eichwald, a Protestant village in northern Germany. He begins by warning that he cannot vouch for every detail: some events reached him through hearsay, and the images sometimes show things he could not have witnessed. That frame matters as the village’s quiet routines give way to assaults and sabotage. Its social order is visible in the baron who owns the estate, the pastor who governs family life, the doctor and teacher whose professions place them between authority and farm laborers who depend on the landowner.
The first disturbance is aimed at the doctor. A nearly invisible wire has been stretched across his path, making his horse throw him and leaving him injured. The film does not supply a culprit. Soon afterward, the wife of a farm worker is killed when rotten boards give way at the estate sawmill. Her husband blames the baron for making them work under dangerous conditions; their son later cuts down the baron’s cabbage crop, and the grieving father hangs himself. Each incident adds another grievance in the village, but the people in charge treat the consequences as isolated trouble rather than evidence of a shared sickness.
At the manor, the harvest festival should display the baron’s generosity to the workers. Instead, his son Sigi disappears and is found the next morning tied up and beaten in the sawmill. The baron dismisses Eva, the nanny, without proof that she was responsible. The schoolteacher has been growing close to her, and the loss complicates their tentative courtship. At Christmas he visits her family and asks her father for permission to marry. Her father agrees only after a year-long trial period, so the relationship has a fragile future even as the village’s more powerful households break apart: the baron’s wife later says she loves another man and plans to leave.
The pastor’s home gives the film another kind of threat. He makes his children wear white ribbons when they have sinned, presenting the strips of cloth as reminders of purity and obedience. His son confesses to touching himself and is punished by having his hands tied to the bed each night. After the pastor humiliates his daughter Klara before the confirmation class, the family’s caged parakeet is found dead on his desk, pinned with scissors in the shape of a cross. Klara has been shown opening the cage with scissors in her hand. The wider series of attacks remains unsolved. Its placement makes the pastor’s demand for moral discipline part of the same atmosphere of punishment that he claims to be correcting.
The doctor’s household has its own hidden violence. He treats the village children with warmth, but humiliates his housekeeper, who is also his lover, the midwife, and sexually abuses his teenage daughter Anna. The film shows the damage through the household’s strained behavior and the way other family members move around the doctor’s authority. The midwife’s son Karli, a disabled boy, is later attacked and nearly blinded. A note beside him quotes a biblical warning about punishing children for their fathers’ sins. The steward’s daughter Erna had earlier described a dream of harm coming to Karli; the wording and timing make the dream another uncertain clue rather than proof.
When the midwife tells the teacher that Karli identified his attacker, she takes his bicycle and leaves to report it to the police. Neither she nor her son returns to the village. The doctor and his family also vanish, leaving only a notice that his practice is closed. Rumors then turn toward them, while the teacher suspects that some of the pastor’s children and their schoolmates knew about the attacks or helped carry them out. He confronts the pastor in the rectory, but the pastor rejects the accusation and threatens to have him jailed if he repeats it. The teacher cannot turn suspicion into evidence, and the children remain protected by the adults who set the rules around them.
Haneke and cinematographer Christian Berger give the story a composed, unshowy visual form. They shot on color stock and converted the images to black and white, which allowed scenes lit by candles and kerosene lamps while keeping the image deliberately removed from a naturalistic historical reconstruction. Haneke said the narrator and monochrome image should remind viewers that they are seeing a memory assembled from uncertain testimony. Long, carefully held views also leave important action outside the frame; the village’s order is often conveyed by who has the right to speak, punish or leave a room. The production drew on period photographs and research into rural education, and the white ribbon itself came from historical child-rearing practices. Constructed and adapted buildings were part of that effect: monochrome concealed differences between new scenery and existing village structures. Digital corrections also replaced modern roofing materials that would otherwise betray the period. The apparently austere image therefore depended on substantial construction and finishing work, alongside the practical light sources visible in the rooms.
The final church gathering takes place after war has begun. The teacher’s prospective father-in-law visits, but the unresolved local violence remains unspoken; the film gives no confession or definitive identification of who committed the attacks. Soon the teacher is drafted and leaves Eichwald, never to return. Haneke closes the narrator’s account with uncertainty rather than a solved mystery: the adults have produced strict ideals and severe punishments, yet the events do not arrange themselves into a neat chain of causes. The film keeps the question of the children’s involvement open, while showing how the village’s authority figures model and enforce the coercion surrounding them.

