Behind the film
- Year
- 2019
- Director
- Fernando Meirelles
- Writers
- Anthony McCarten
- Runtime
- 2h 5m
- Genres
- Drama, Historical, Biographical
- Production
- Netflix
- Country
- United Kingdom, Italy, Argentina, United States
- Cast
- Anthony Hopkins, Jonathan Pryce, Luis Gnecco, Cristina Banegas, Renato Scarpa, Germán de Silva, Libero De Rienzo, Vincent Riotta
About the film
Contains story spoilers.
The Two Popes imagines a private meeting at a moment when the Catholic Church’s future is uncertain. Jonathan Pryce plays Cardinal Jorge Bergoglio, the future Pope Francis, opposite Anthony Hopkins as Pope Benedict XVI. Bergoglio wants to retire from his position in Buenos Aires; Benedict summons him to Italy, where their disagreement about the institution becomes an increasingly personal conversation. Tradition, reform and the responsibilities of leadership share space with television, food and jokes. Flashbacks take Bergoglio’s story back to Argentina, placing his later humility beside memories of authority and failure. Fernando Meirelles’s film moves between these intimate exchanges and the scale of Vatican ceremony, with the two men’s different ways of speaking and behaving carrying a debate about what change might require. Close-ups and two-shots give their expressions and body language a place alongside the words.
In the film’s account, Benedict refuses Bergoglio’s resignation because accepting it would look like a loss of confidence in his leadership. He then reveals his own intention to leave the papacy, startling Bergoglio into defending continuity. Bergoglio recalls failing to protect fellow priests under Argentina’s military dictatorship; Benedict offers absolution. Benedict, in turn, confesses his awareness of Marcial Maciel’s misconduct and says that he no longer hears God’s voice. Bergoglio comforts him and offers absolution. Their encounter ends with a warmer understanding between them, rather than agreement on every question. A year later, Benedict resigns and Bergoglio is elected Pope Francis. The closing football scene brings the two together to watch Germany face Argentina in the 2014 World Cup final. These private exchanges belong to the film’s dramatization, rather than a transcript of documented conversations.
Screenwriter Anthony McCarten found the project’s starting question while visiting Rome after a death in his family. Looking for somewhere to light a candle, he reached St Peter’s Square and encountered a crowd watching Francis. Learning that Benedict was living nearby made the coexistence of two popes suddenly tangible. He wanted to understand why a leader so associated with tradition had made the unusual decision to resign. The resulting screenplay uses that apparent contradiction to put two positions into conversation. McCarten was explicit about the limits of his material: nobody had supplied him with the intimate talks, and the theological debate was his invention. He researched the men’s publicly stated views as the basis for speculation. That distinction matters throughout the film. Its dialogue can explore how an encounter might develop, but it cannot establish what either man actually admitted in private.
McCarten also described a movement from argument toward listening. He saw the men’s experiences of doubt, dictatorship and spiritual leadership as possible grounds for understanding beneath their differences. In his conception, the initial exchanges resemble opponents trading blows; the quieter antechamber scene gives that contest somewhere to stop. The screenplay’s visual decisions include which room a conversation occupies and how the characters enter or leave it, while the director adds details beyond the written dialogue. McCarten singled out the conclave’s red robes and clicking blue pens as one such addition. The production sought physical connections to the real lives behind the fiction, too. The younger Bergoglio’s moment of religious calling was filmed in the actual confessional associated with that experience. The result combines invented conversation with carefully chosen locations, allowing the setting to carry historical associations that the dialogue itself cannot verify.
Meirelles wanted the film to feel personal and funny rather than remain an extended discussion of doctrine. He took inspiration from the intimate treatment of royalty in The Queen, imagining his central pair as uncles who could eat pizza and watch football together. His understanding of Benedict changed during preparation: instead of treating him simply as the obstacle to Francis, he came to understand his belief that tradition connects people to God. Hopkins’s research and warmth helped develop that approach. The younger Bergoglio, played by Juan Minujín, was another deliberate contrast. Meirelles did not want Minujín and Pryce to share a conspicuous gesture merely to signal that they were the same person. The character’s change over time was more important than a matching mannerism. The casting therefore allows youth and age to look different, reinforcing the history of self-reckoning that the story places behind the older man’s conduct.
The Vatican interiors required reconstruction. Production designer Mark Tildesley studied the Sistine Chapel and the adjoining Room of Tears, where the film places a shared pizza. Hand-painting the frescoes would have taken too long, while ordinary paper printing would have looked flat. Instead, the team transferred images into plaster, letting the ink absorb into the walls and retain their texture and bright colour. The process took about eight weeks. Exterior access to Castel Gandolfo supplied the arrival shot, while other palaces provided interiors and gardens. The imposing spaces are thus a mixture of actual locations and constructed rooms.

