Behind the film
- Year
- 1931
- Director
- William A. Wellman
- Writers
- Kubec Glasmon, Harvey F. Thew
- Runtime
- 1h 23m
- Genres
- Drama, Crime, Film noir, Suspense
- Production
- Warner Bros. Entertainment, Warner Bros. Pictures
- Country
- United States
- Cast
- James Cagney, Jean Harlow, Edward Woods, Joan Blondell, Leslie Fenton, Beryl Mercer, Mae Clarke, Donald Cook
About the film
Contains story spoilers.
William A. Wellman's The Public Enemy is a 1931 Warner Bros. gangster film starring James Cagney as Tom Powers and Edward Woods as his friend Matt Doyle. Jean Harlow plays Gwen Allen, Mae Clarke is Kitty and Joan Blondell is Mamie. Donald Cook plays Tom's brother Mike, with Beryl Mercer as their mother. The film follows Tom from childhood into the Prohibition liquor business, putting his success beside the damage he does to people around him. John Bright, Kubec Glasmon and Harvey Thew contributed the writing, while the black-and-white photography and early sound recording place the criminal story within crowded streets, bars and domestic rooms.
Tom and Matt begin by stealing and running errands for Putty Nose, an older criminal who gives them access to a world beyond their immediate families. The boys' apprenticeship becomes dangerous when a robbery goes wrong and Putty Nose abandons them. The friendship survives that betrayal, but their relationship with their first mentor changes. As adults, they enter the beer racket under Paddy Ryan and Nails Nathan. Prohibition creates a market that rewards their willingness to intimidate and steal. They acquire money and clothes without leaving the criminal hierarchy behind: Tom's visible prosperity depends on working for men with greater control over the business.
At home, Tom's earnings divide his family. His mother welcomes him and wants to see his gifts as signs of affection, while Mike refuses to overlook where the money comes from. Mike has returned from military service and challenges his brother's account of success. At a family meal, the beer Tom provides becomes the object of their argument. Tom responds to Mike's condemnation by bringing up the killing associated with war. The brothers' disagreement moves between their own conduct and the authority to judge each other, leaving their mother between two sons whose standards cannot be reconciled by the occasion of a homecoming.
Tom also uses force in his personal relationships. Over breakfast, he pushes half a grapefruit into Kitty's face, turning an ordinary exchange into an act of humiliation. The scene makes his aggression visible without a gunfight or a rival gangster in the room. Kitty has no part in the professional conflict that later threatens him; she is subjected to the same impulse to dominate in a domestic setting. The episode became closely associated with Cagney's screen image. Accounts of its filming differ over how much Clarke expected, so the action within the story is clearer than any single explanation of its preparation.
Tom eventually encounters Putty Nose again and kills him, settling the betrayal from their earlier robbery. Another death then disrupts the organisation protecting Tom and Matt: Nails Nathan is thrown from a horse and dies. Tom responds by buying the horse and shooting it. His response directs revenge at an animal rather than a human rival, carrying his habit of retaliation into an accident. Nails's absence also leaves the gang exposed. Rival criminals move against Paddy Ryan's people, and the money and confidence of the earlier rise give way to hiding, uncertainty and the threat of an attack outside the door.
Matt is killed when the friends leave their hiding place and are caught in a street ambush. Tom goes after the rival gang and emerges badly wounded, eventually reaching a hospital where his family visits him. His weakened condition briefly allows the prospect of a different relationship with Mike and their mother. That possibility is destroyed when rival gangsters take him from the hospital. At home, the family expects his return and his mother prepares his bed. Mike opens the front door to find Tom's dead, bandaged body propped upright on the threshold. It falls forward, bringing the gang war directly into the house.
Cagney and Woods had originally been assigned the opposite roles. Wellman changed the arrangement early in production, placing Cagney's abrupt speech and physical energy at the centre as Tom. His movements carry aggression into moments before any blow is struck: a grin, a lean and a relaxed posture can become ways of challenging another person. Later, wounded in the rain, Tom loses that assurance and acknowledges his own vulnerability. The film's account of his rise therefore depends on changes in the same body that first seemed able to brush aside advice, insult his brother and act without considering the aftermath.
Much of the gun violence takes place outside the frame, making sound and the visible result carry the action. The noise of a coal truck helps prepare the street ambush, while the final return to the Powers house sets household activity beside a concealed horror. Music also changes its function across the film: the light tune associated with the opening returns on a phonograph near the end. The domestic setting can no longer protect the family from Tom's criminal life. A closing title card condemns that life, following an image that has already shown its cost through the body at the door and the mother's unfinished preparations upstairs.

