Behind the film
- Year
- 1996
- Director
- Miloš Forman
- Writers
- Scott Alexander, Larry Karaszewski
- Runtime
- 2h 10m
- Genres
- Biographical, Drama, Trial, Lgbtq-related
- Production
- Phoenix Pictures
- Country
- United States
- Cast
- Woody Harrelson, Courtney Love, Edward Norton, Richard Paul, James Cromwell, Donna Hanover, Crispin Glover, Vincent Schiavelli
About the film
Contains story spoilers.
The People vs. Larry Flynt follows a Cincinnati strip-club proprietor whose plan to improve business becomes a much larger publishing enterprise. Larry turns an explicitly illustrated newsletter into Hustler magazine, gaining money and notoriety along with a succession of opponents. Woody Harrelson plays Flynt, Courtney Love plays his wife Althea, and Edward Norton plays attorney Alan Isaacman. The lawyer's commitment to civil liberties brings him into a difficult working relationship with a client who enjoys provoking authority. Obscenity prosecutions become one part of a career spent testing what can be printed and said. The magazine's success supplies resources for those fights while making its publisher a conspicuous target.
The film carries Larry and Althea through prosperity, a brief religious conversion and the violence that transforms their lives. A shooting outside a Georgia courthouse leaves Larry paralyzed, and his pain and despair lead into drug addiction. Althea also becomes addicted. Surgery eventually helps Larry resume an active role in the magazine, but his behavior in court repeatedly endangers the help Isaacman can offer. He insults judges, wears an American flag as a diaper and turns legal proceedings into spectacles. A parody advertisement about evangelist Jerry Falwell brings another lawsuit, this time over libel and emotional distress. Meanwhile, Althea reveals that she has AIDS and later drowns in their bathtub.
After losing Althea, Larry asks Isaacman to take the Falwell case to the Supreme Court. Their damaged professional relationship has to be repaired before the appeal can proceed. In the courtroom, Isaacman argues that punishment based on a public figure's hurt feelings would threaten satire even where nobody believes the offending publication is true. Larry listens while his lawyer makes that distinction. The decision is unanimous in his favor, but the ending turns from the public victory to private absence. Alone in his bedroom, Larry watches home movies of himself and a healthy Althea. Winning the case cannot restore the person who shared his life before the final legal battle.
Screenwriters Scott Alexander and Larry Karaszewski recalled their fascination with Flynt in an On Story conversation. As college roommates, they had followed reports of his courtroom antics and seen material for comedy in his refusal to behave as a defendant was expected to behave. After Ed Wood, they hoped to get another unconventional biography made. Oliver Stone was their first choice of director and responded to the project, but his commitment to Nixon opened the way for Miloš Forman. The writers connected Forman to the outsider figures in his earlier work and to his experience of a government suppressing unwelcome speech. They also resisted making Isaacman the central character simply to give viewers a more conventional person to identify with. Keeping Flynt at the center required the film to follow the troublesome subject himself.
Compressing that subject's life demanded choices beyond deciding which trial to include. Alexander told an interviewer that the Flynt script began at 214 pages. He described the pair's extensive index-card planning and the difficulty of cutting biographies after gathering so much appealing material. His example of a necessary simplification was the legal representation: three lawyers involved in three major trials became one lawyer in the film. That decision gives Isaacman a continuous relationship with Flynt across events that did not originally share a single advocate. Alexander defended combining people who served the same dramatic function while staying true to the subject's intentions. The resulting courtroom relationship therefore belongs to the screenplay's organization of history as well as to the cases it dramatizes.
Forman's casting combined professional performers with people connected to the world being portrayed. He told BOMB that he chose among three very different screen tests for Althea, ultimately fighting studio resistance to cast Love. The real Flynt played the judge at his first obscenity trial, and the surgeon who had operated on his spine also appeared. Forman tested nonprofessional performers to see whether their presence worked on camera. He put similar value on the atmosphere among his stars, describing Harrelson, Love and Norton as contributors to a relaxed set. His preference for improvisation could complicate the cinematographer's lighting when actors moved freely. For him, directing involved leaving space for that freedom rather than fixing every aspect of a performance in advance.
That approach produced practical consequences for shooting and editing. Editor Christopher Tellefsen recalled that scenes between Love and Harrelson were often covered with two cameras because her improvisation could surprise her partner. CineMontage's production history describes Memphis locations standing in for several states and the city's train terminal becoming a full-sized Supreme Court chamber. The courtroom scenes generated coverage of individual jurors as well as the principal speakers. Tellefsen remembered working through many alternative cuts at Forman's request and facing roughly 800,000 feet of footage. The material gave the editing room many possible reactions and exchanges to choose from, with a three-hour first cut eventually reduced to the theatrical length. The apparent spontaneity depended on a large amount of photographed material being shaped afterward.
The choice to organize the story around Flynt also shaped the criticism it received. Time Out praised the courtroom comedy and the three leading performances while arguing that the film made its subject too comfortably heroic. Its review objected that Hustler's exploitation of women went largely unexamined and that Flynt's opponents were reduced too heavily to hypocrisy and intolerance. That criticism addresses the limits of the film's chosen perspective: following a publisher through a free-expression case does not necessarily account for everything his publication did. The public argument about the film consequently extended beyond whether its courtroom victory was convincing.

