Behind the film
- Year
- 2001
- Director
- Joel Coen
- Writers
- Coen brothers
- Genres
- Neo-noir, Drama, Crime
- Production
- Working Title Films, Gramercy Pictures, Good Machine
- Country
- United Kingdom, United States
- Cast
- Billy Bob Thornton, Frances McDormand, Michael Badalucco, Richard Jenkins, Scarlett Johansson, Adam Alexi-Malle, Jon Polito, Tony Shalhoub
About the film
Contains story spoilers, including the ending.
The Man Who Wasn't There follows Ed Crane, a quiet barber in Santa Rosa in 1949. Billy Bob Thornton plays Ed, with Frances McDormand as his wife Doris and James Gandolfini as her department-store boss, Big Dave. Ed works beside his talkative brother-in-law Frank, but does not think of barbering as his identity. A customer, Creighton Tolliver, offers a chance to invest in dry cleaning. Ed sees a way to leave his routine and raises the money by anonymously blackmailing Big Dave over his affair with Doris. The scheme draws on an intimacy Ed has already noticed while sitting quietly among them. Big Dave even confides his distress about the blackmail to Ed, unaware that he is speaking to its author. The Coens' 2001 story begins with a man whose silence allows him to listen, then lets him act on what other people assume he does not know.
Big Dave discovers Ed's involvement and attacks him; Ed kills him in self-defence. The financial trail instead points to Doris, who is arrested. Ed hires Freddy Riedenschneider to defend her, but she hangs herself before the case reaches trial. Ed learns that she was pregnant, although they had not been intimate for years. He turns towards Birdy Abundas and imagines a future managing her as a concert pianist. A teacher rejects her prospects. Birdy's sexual advance on the drive home distracts Ed, and the car crashes. He wakes in hospital facing another charge: Tolliver's body has been found with the investment agreement, and the police blame Ed for his death. Frank attacks Ed during the trial, causing a mistrial and leaving the defence without enough money to continue as before. Ed is eventually sentenced to execution for a killing he did not commit. Waiting on death row, he sells his story to a magazine. The narration ends with his thoughts about Doris and the possibility of seeing her again as he is taken to the electric chair.
Music offers Ed a glimpse of the different life he cannot clearly describe. Composer Carter Burwell identified Birdy's Beethoven sonatas as the thing that truly moves him. Burwell and music editor Todd Kasow began their musical discussions with those pieces, and Kasow gathered sonatas that might suit Ed and the film. That connection made the piano central to Burwell's own score, although he did not intend to imitate Beethoven. Many of its structures repeat in cycles, expressing Ed's inability to escape his circumstances. The Coens also wanted a suggestion of yearning: Ed wants something else without knowing exactly what it is. Hearing Birdy gives that desire a temporary shape. His interest in her playing therefore has a place in the music beyond the plan to become her manager. Burwell's account connects the piano with the barber's private hopes, including hopes he cannot put into conversation.
Roger Deakins developed the black-and-white photography through tests with different negatives and print stocks. The Coens had written the film with that presentation in mind, but the modest budget made the amount of light needed for slower black-and-white stock a concern. Deakins tested colour negative and worked with Beverly Wood at Deluxe on a black-and-white print. A high-contrast stock normally used for titles gave them a result they liked after changes to its development. The colour negative also satisfied a contractual requirement for a colour version for European video markets. Lighting still varied within the monochrome theatrical design. The jail visiting room uses harsh window light while Riedenschneider talks about uncertainty; the approach to the electric chair becomes flat and bright, with white walls suggesting a void. Ed's daytime barbershop, built on the Paramount backlot, needed large reflected lights because little daylight entered the set. The Cranes' home combined a Pasadena exterior with matching studio interiors. Its rooms had to connect in the order the Coens' writing required, allowing the camera to see back from the porch towards the kitchen. Long-held shots gave viewers time to study each composition, making its shapes and balance of light especially important.
Deakins said that lighting for black and white made him aware of composition, depth and the direction of light within each frame. He felt that removing colour could concentrate attention on the subject. Although the camera recorded colour negative, he lit The Man Who Wasn't There for its intended black-and-white appearance. He wanted a period feeling without simply repeating the lighting of an old film. His long collaboration with Joel and Ethan Coen also made it possible to take chances. Familiarity gave him confidence to push a choice further while working with people he knew well. He described each of their scripts as requiring its own photographic response. For Ed's story, the look was decided around this small-town setting and this character, with the monochrome image planned during photography rather than treated as a finishing decoration.

