V4mp

Explore V4mp

Find your next route. Get back to playing.

← Back to the film shelf
The Heiress poster
V4mp Cinema

The Heiress

1949 · William Wyler

In nineteenth-century New York, Catherine Sloper falls for Morris Townsend, a charming young man her father suspects of pursuing her inheritance. William Wyler's The Heiress follows Catherine's struggle to trust his love while living under a father's contempt, with Olivia de Havilland playing the sheltered daughter.

DramaRomanceHistorical drama

Behind the film

Year
1949
Director
William Wyler
Writers
Henry James
Genres
Drama, Romance, Historical drama
Production
Paramount Pictures
Country
United States
Cast
Olivia de Havilland, Montgomery Clift, Ralph Richardson, Miriam Hopkins, Mona Freeman, Vanessa Brown, Harry Antrim, Ray Collins

About the film

Contains story spoilers.

Catherine Sloper lives with her father, Dr. Austin Sloper, and her aunt Lavinia in New York's Washington Square. Her father compares her unfavourably with her dead mother. Lavinia encourages Morris Townsend's courtship, but Sloper suspects a fortune hunter. Morris's sister confirms he squandered his inheritance and has no work. Sloper takes Catherine to Europe to separate them; she remains determined to marry Morris. De Havilland had already imagined Catherine differently from the woman she saw on stage. In her Academy of Achievement interview, she remembers admiring Wendy Hiller's performance while finding it too stylized for the screen. By the end of the second act, she wanted the role herself. Two directors she considered were unavailable, so her representative persuaded Wyler to see the play in New York. She recalls waiting for his promised telephone call afterwards. His agreement gave her the director she needed for a Catherine whose feelings could be expressed without the stage performance's stylization.

The American Film Institute's catalogue records an earlier, unrealized plan to film the play with its original Broadway cast. Wyler's project passed from Liberty Films to Paramount when the studio absorbed the company. One performer did carry her part from the original American stage production into this film: Betty Linley, playing Morris's sister, Mrs. Montgomery. The house became central to the screen adaptation. Pamela Hutchinson's Criterion essay describes Harry Horner's sets, with their staircase and mirrors, as places where family power takes visible form. Catherine's reflection recalls her father's judgment: she permits herself only a brief look of admiration after Morris proposes. Later, when their relationship has broken down, she speaks to her father through his reflection. Hutchinson connects these arrangements with Wyler's careful blocking and use of depth, finding emotional pressure within rooms that might otherwise seem merely comfortable.

That pressure depends on a father who can be right about a suitor and cruel to his daughter at the same time. In his Library of America essay, David Denby finds Ralph Richardson holding both qualities together: Sloper's accurate suspicion grows alongside resentment and contempt. Denby also locates Morris's appeal in Montgomery Clift's hesitant gentleness and self-deprecating humour. His Morris needs approval, including from the man whose comfortable life he wants to enjoy. Catherine's attraction therefore has more to sustain it than an obviously villainous suitor would offer. Denby sees the camera and editing favouring de Havilland's feelings, especially her gradual recognition that her father's opinion comes from contempt. Her discovery of his hostility becomes a scene of understanding, with the daughter registering what the father has allowed himself to reveal. When Sloper threatens disinheritance, Catherine asks Morris to elope immediately and tells him she will reject her father's money. Morris agrees to arrange their escape. She waits with packed bags, but he never arrives.

Aaron Copland remembered the music changing how an audience responded to that wait. In a conversation preserved by the American Archive of Public Broadcasting, the composer describes writing a romantic, excited cue to express Catherine's feelings as she listens for the carriage that should take her away. At a preview, he recalled, spectators laughed when she rushed out and the carriage continued past the house. Wyler asked him for music that would make the moment serious. Copland replaced the original cue with tense, dissonant music, and said the next audience did not laugh. He thought listeners might not even notice the score consciously, although its atmosphere affected their response. His account makes the choice of music part of the scene's sympathy for Catherine: the same disappointed expectation had prompted laughter before the replacement directed attention towards her distress. Copland presents that change as a satisfaction particular to composing for a film, where music helps determine how a dramatic situation is understood.

The performers' work together involved another kind of adjustment. Speaking to Josephine Reed for the National Endowment for the Arts, de Havilland recalled admiring Wyler and trying to understand his intention even when his instructions were difficult to follow. Working with Clift was confusing for her in a different way. She said he rehearsed their scenes each evening with his personal coach, then seemed to play towards the coach rather than towards her on set. According to de Havilland, he also sought the coach's reaction after rehearsals. She found a point of view that let her use the difficulty within the scene, though it required adaptation. Her recollection includes respect for the trouble Clift took over his work. It describes her experience of finding a workable relationship between scene partners whose preparations differed.

Catherine refuses to visit her dying father, then inherits his fortune. Years later Morris returns. She proposes their delayed elopement, lets him leave to pack, then bolts the door. He pounds outside while she goes upstairs alone. Hutchinson reads this second ascent against Catherine's earlier climb after being abandoned. De Havilland's voice deepens as Catherine hardens, and the staircase changes from a route of humiliation into an assertion of ownership. The embroidery offers a quieter measure of that change. Catherine's alphabet progresses through the story; she cuts the final thread on Z before the closing ascent. Hutchinson notes that Ruth and Augustus Goetz, who adapted their play for the screen, added this second jilting for the film. Catherine can now impose the rejection once inflicted on her. The home and the final choice belong to her, though her new authority takes the form of deliberately making Morris wait in vain.

Keep exploring

Meet the editors

Two seats. Two perspectives.

V4mp and Baby Bat.
A shared love of stories, with room for different takes.

V
V4mpFILMS & GAMES

One half of Dead Good Reviews.

B
Baby BatFILMS, BOOKS & GAMES

The curator behind Baby Bat’s Library.