Behind the film
- Year
- 1937
- Director
- Leo McCarey
- Writers
- Viña Delmar, Sidney Buchman
- Genres
- Comedy of remarriage, Romantic comedy
- Production
- Columbia Pictures
- Country
- United States
- Cast
- Cary Grant, Irene Dunne, Ralph Bellamy, Alexander D'Arcy, Cecil Cunningham, Molly Lamont, Robert Warwick, Esther Dale
About the film
Contains story spoilers.
Jerry and Lucy Warriner suspect each other of infidelity and decide to divorce. Lucy wins custody of their dog, Mr. Smith, while Jerry receives visiting rights. Aunt Patsy introduces Lucy to Daniel Leeson, an Oklahoma oilman who becomes her prospective second husband. Jerry interrupts their courtship and tries to wreck the engagement, yet defends Lucy when Daniel's mother attacks her reputation. After Lucy and Daniel separate, Jerry turns to heiress Barbara Vance. Lucy visits the Vance household posing as Jerry's sister, feigns drunkenness and performs an embarrassing parody of a nightclub act. Her behaviour makes Jerry take her away. She then gets him to Patsy's cabin, where their confrontation gives way to reconciliation just before midnight, when the divorce is due to become final.
Leo McCarey's 1937 film retains the trial-divorce premise of Arthur Richman's 1922 play, which had already been filmed twice. The Library of Congress describes the adaptation as expanding the dialogue and encouraging the actors to improvise. The film entered the National Film Registry in 1996. Molly Haskell, writing for Criterion, identifies a further change in the adaptation: the earlier versions clear the woman's reputation unequivocally, whereas this film leaves Lucy's innocence less settled. Jerry's defence of her cannot resolve every doubt. Their social position is similarly awkward. Haskell places them close to fashionable society without making them its guardians of respectability. They know the right people, but their conduct repeatedly disturbs the good manners around them. The possibility of embarrassment belongs to both spouses, rather than falling only on the woman whose reputation is being discussed.
That instability appears in the staging as well as the dialogue. Haskell describes Jerry sitting on the back of a sofa, legs crossed at an odd angle, while the people around him occupy the room more conventionally. His body breaks the orderly arrangement. The encounter involving Lucy's voice teacher Armand moves through two-shots, three-shots and close-ups, changing the emphasis within an uncomfortable triangle. Mr. Smith snatches hats, exposing the fragility of male dignity, while a lawyer's noisy wife interrupts his attempt to discourage divorce. McCarey's account to Peter Bogdanovich describes another scene beginning with a fixed camera position at Lucy's door. He knew Jerry would arrive and Lucy would admit him. Their exchange about his court-ordered visit to the dog then supplied the scene's direction.
In that interview, McCarey remembered improvising dialogue and scenes while knowing where each belonged in the story. He could leave the studio knowing the next situation without having settled what the actors would say. Such uncertainty did not suit everyone. McCarey told Bogdanovich that Grant wanted to withdraw after filming had begun and offered Harry Cohn compensation for the expense. The studio kept him in the picture. McCarey said the tension continued, and specifically denied that Dunne had also wanted to leave. His recollection describes a working relationship that remained difficult even though the actors continued making the film together. His 1965 interview with Serge Daney and Jean-Louis Noames gives a different recollection: he remembered enjoying the shoot and having no trouble with the three leads. He also called it one of his fastest productions. McCarey said some marital misunderstandings drew on his own life, while insisting that the scenes about unfaithfulness came from his imagination.
Ralph Bellamy's memories bring that uncertainty down to a specific performance. He recalled arriving without dialogue for his scene and finding Dunne at a piano playing Home on the Range. McCarey asked whether he could sing. Bellamy admitted his limitations, but the director filmed him singing with Dunne anyway and kept the result. Dunne's recollection of the sister impersonation describes a different mixture of preparation and adjustment. The scene was written over a weekend and given to her on the morning of filming. When she could not manage a planned burlesque movement, McCarey had her acknowledge the failure aloud. That response stayed in the picture. Dunne also credited a crew member with suggesting the ending in which a male clock figure follows a female figure through her door. McCarey's limited coverage left fewer alternative ways to assemble scenes, keeping the eventual edit close to his intentions.
Stanley Cavell's introduction at the Harvard Film Archive places the couple within what he calls remarriage comedy. In his reading, the central pair already know each other intimately when the story starts; separation gives them a reason to reconsider what that knowledge means. He connects the courtroom struggle over Mr. Smith with their lack of children, and contrasts Aunt Patsy's support for Lucy's freedom with the interference of Daniel's mother. His reading of Home on the Range is more specific than a judgement that Daniel sings badly. Daniel knows business, but cannot recognise Lucy's musical accomplishment, asking whether she has ever taken lessons. For Cavell, that failure prevents him from understanding the woman he wants to marry. Jerry's humiliations, including his fall from a chair and borrowed nightshirt, belong to the same examination of intimacy. Cavell also connects the move out of the city to the country cabin with the couple finding greater clarity about their relationship.

