Behind the film
- Year
- 1927
- Director
- F. W. Murnau
- Writers
- Carl Mayer, Hermann Sudermann
- Runtime
- 1h 31m
- Genres
- Drama, Silent, Romance
- Production
- 20th Century Studios
- Country
- United States
- Cast
- Janet Gaynor, Margaret Livingston, George O'Brien, Jane Winton, Arthur Housman, J. Farrell MacDonald, Robert Parrish, Gino Corrado
About the film
Contains story spoilers.
The Woman from the city has been staying in a rural village and begins an affair with a married farmer known only as the Man. One night she signals to him from outside his window; he leaves his wife and baby asleep at home and crosses the marsh to meet her. The encounter is tender at first, but it becomes a proposal: she wants him to sell the farm and join her in the city. When she tells him to drown his wife and make it look like an accident, his response is a burst of violence. He nearly strangles her, then embraces her again as she turns his attention toward the exciting life she imagines for them. She gathers reeds and shows him how they might keep him afloat if he overturns the boat. He carries them home, hides them in the barn and lies beside his wife, who tenderly covers him as he sleeps through a troubled dream of water.
The next morning, the Man asks his wife to take a boat ride with him. She accepts without knowing that he means to kill her; he brings the concealed reeds and imagines pushing her overboard as he rows. When he stands over her, she cowers, and her fear breaks through the plan he has been following. He sits down again and keeps paddling. At the far bank, she leaps from the boat and runs up the slope. He catches her and begs her not to fear him, but she pulls away and boards a streetcar. He follows her into the city, where she is still shaken and nearly struck by a car. The Man pulls her clear, then takes her to a café and offers her cakes. She begins to cry, and his effort to comfort her is quiet and awkward; the trip has not erased what he nearly did.
The city gives the couple a string of chances to choose one another again. The Man buys his wife flowers, and when they see a bride and groom entering a church, they follow them inside. The minister's words about protecting a bride from harm reach the Man as a promise he has failed to keep. His wife comforts him while he repeats the vows, and they leave the church arm in arm. Their imaginations briefly return them to the open countryside, although they are still surrounded by city streets. A visit to a barber and a photography studio turns grooming and a portrait into further gestures of reconciliation; the photographer captures the couple as they kiss. These details give the day a ritual shape, moving from her fear in the street to a public image of the two of them together.
They spend the later hours at a carnival. The Wife watches other couples dance, and the Man joins her on the floor; a drink and fireworks give their outing a more carefree rhythm. As night settles, they take the boat back across the water, and she falls asleep while he draws her shawl around her. The return journey brings the earlier plan back into the story. A storm breaks over the lake, waking her and making the boat difficult to control. The Man retrieves the reeds he hid in the hull and ties them around his wife so she can stay afloat if they capsize. The boat overturns, and they are thrown into the water. When the weather clears, he reaches shore but cannot find her. The reeds that began as equipment for a murder have become his attempt to save her.
The Woman from the city hears the commotion and joins the villagers searching the shoreline. When the Man sees loose reeds drifting on the water, he assumes his wife has drowned. He returns home, kneels beside her empty bed and grieves. The other woman arrives to claim the future she had asked him to choose, but his despair turns to rage: he chases and begins to strangle her. A messenger arrives with news that his wife has been found alive. He lets the Woman go and rushes to his wife's bedside. As the sun rises, she wakes and kisses him, while the city visitor leaves the village. The ending closes the near-tragedy with a reconciliation, though the wife's trust has already been shaken and the Man's actions remain part of what brought them to this moment.
Murnau uses movement and changes in space to carry the story. The village has the shape of a fairy tale, while the city is crowded with traffic, dance and lights. The tram makes that shift physical, carrying the couple away from the water where the Man planned violence. In the silent format, gestures and intertitles take the place of dialogue; one title card lets the word for the proposed drowning slide down as if sinking. The credits place the story nowhere in particular, while the Man, Wife and Woman are defined by the choices that bring them to this lake and this storm.

