Behind the film
- Year
- 2012
- Director
- Scott Derrickson
- Writers
- Scott Derrickson, C. Robert Cargill
- Runtime
- 1h 45m
- Genres
- Horror, Mystery, Ghost
- Production
- IM Global, Summit Entertainment, Alliance Films
- Country
- United States, United Kingdom, Canada
- Cast
- Ethan Hawke, Fred Thompson, Vincent D'Onofrio, Juliet Rylance, James Ransone, Clare Foley
About the film
Contains story spoilers.
Ellison hides the house's history from his wife Tracy, hoping another crime book will revive his career. In its attic he discovers films of murdered families. A deputy connects the cases: each family lost a child, and one occupied a previous victim's home. Professor Jonas identifies the figure in the footage as Bughuul, the story's fictional child-consuming entity. As ghost children haunt the house, Ellison burns the films and takes his family home. The deputy's warning comes too late: moving away completes the pattern. The restored reels reveal that the missing children committed the murders under Bughuul's influence. Ashley drugs Ellison, kills him, Tracy and her brother Trevor, and records their deaths. Her promise to make her father famous again turns his ambition against him. Bughuul takes Ashley's soul, continuing the cycle.
That box of films began with C. Robert Cargill's own nightmare after watching The Ring. He dreamed of finding Super 8 reels in his attic and projecting the image that became Sinister's opening. The idea stayed with him for years before he recognised a story in it. Cargill brought the pitch to Scott Derrickson, but the screenplay was their joint work from the beginning. Living in different parts of the country and keeping different schedules let them pass pages back and forth almost continuously. Phone conversations and Skype calls accompanied revisions, taking them from pitch to a completed script in five weeks. Cargill described character motivation and consistent supernatural rules as the foundations: viewers should understand why someone acts even when they disagree. He also singled out a familiar scare they deliberately avoided, the figure appearing behind someone in a mirror and disappearing when that person turns around.
Ethan Hawke approached Ellison through the life he believes he has lost. Speaking about the role, he described ambition damaging a man's relationships and leaving him unable to appreciate what remains good in his life. Ellison longs for his earlier success, making the supernatural story depend on recognisable disappointments and choices. Hawke felt those conflicts could belong in a drama, even though here they admit a literal demon into the household. The confined shoot helped him inhabit that obsession. Working at night in the house with the crew gave the experience a dreamlike isolation, while Ellison's imagination made the story feel larger to him than its central location. Hawke also recalled extensive preparation and rehearsal because the small budget left little room for unnecessary footage. He credited Derrickson with giving the collaborators a shared understanding of the film, so the finished version closely resembled the one they had worked towards.
Cargill used the sheriff's early confrontation with Ellison to establish that character without stopping for a separate explanation. Much of the speech came directly from his original pitch, and he wrote the sheriff with Fred Thompson in mind. Although they were warned Thompson might be difficult to secure, the actor read the script and agreed. Cargill described the exchange as exposition disguised as two men needling each other, carrying information about Ellison and the danger ahead inside their argument. The investigation also drew on Paul Schrader's Hardcore: Cargill wanted attention on Ellison's reaction to the films, taking a cue from George C. Scott watching footage of his daughter. For Mr. Boogie, he assembled ideas from folklore into a new creature. His first imagined appearance included a shabby top hat and tails, like a distorted, undead Willy Wonka. Derrickson instead found a face on Flickr that Cargill recognised as the character, changing the visual direction from that original description.
The films Ellison watches have their own texture within the larger story. Derrickson described their gritty appearance as a deliberate contrast with the surrounding, conventionally filmed horror, giving the reels the feeling of images someone should not be seeing. He treated Sinister as the story of a person discovering footage, with the Super 8 sequences supplying the found-footage component. Sound helped distinguish those sequences too. Derrickson selected prerecorded tracks to accompany them and played that music during shooting to establish the unsettling mood on set. For the rest of the film, he used a temporary score while editing before bringing in Christopher Young. Young's work on The Grudge helped suggest the sound Derrickson was seeking. The director also recalled that prospective studios had asked for a different ending before distribution was settled. Summit supported the existing conclusion without asking the filmmakers to change it.
Derrickson linked that freedom to the film's relatively low cost. In his account, the initial distribution commitment was for a limited release, with a wider release dependent on its response at a test screening. The response cleared that condition. Cargill said notes from financiers and producers asked them to make the film scarier rather than soften it. He described the screenplay as intended for PG-13, while the finished images received an R rating. Derrickson identified disturbing images and terror as the reason and said the distributors did not ask him to reduce them.

