Behind the film
- Year
- 2007
- Director
- Richard LaGravenese
- Writers
- Richard LaGravenese, Steven Rogers
- Genres
- Romantic comedy, Drama
- Production
- Alcon Entertainment, Grosvenor Park Productions, 2S Films
- Country
- United States
- Cast
- Hilary Swank, Gerard Butler, Lisa Kudrow, Harry Connick Jr., Gina Gershon, Jeffrey Dean Morgan, Kathy Bates, James Marsters
About the film
Contains story spoilers, including the ending.
P.S. I Love You follows Holly Kennedy through a year in which her husband keeps speaking to her after his death. Hilary Swank plays Holly and Gerard Butler plays Gerry, who has prepared messages to arrive when she is left to manage without him. The first reaches her on her thirtieth birthday. Others offer instructions meant to get her moving again, carrying the teasing familiarity of a marriage into a life where one partner is missing. Richard LaGravenese's 2007 film gives this arrangement a double pull. Gerry knows how to encourage Holly, but every new message also reminds her that he cannot come back. The letters create occasions for change without making grief disappear on schedule. Holly has to carry out the suggestions herself, among people who are still present and have their own hopes for her.
The trip to Ireland brings Holly together with her friends Denise and Sharon, then confronts her with how quickly their lives are changing. Stranded in a fishing boat after losing their oars, the women share news: Denise is getting married and Sharon is pregnant. Holly has to hear both while facing the future she has lost. William, a singer they have encountered at a pub, rescues them. He and Holly become involved, then discover that Gerry connects them in another way: William was his childhood friend. He can tell stories about Gerry that Holly does not know, allowing their relationship to hold a shared affection for the man who has died. Holly also visits Gerry's parents and receives another letter. Ireland brings the marriage's beginning back into view, alongside the awkwardness of being attracted to someone new.
Back in New York, Holly begins to find work she wants to pursue for herself. A suspender clip belonging to Gerry catches her attention on a shoe and helps spark an interest in designing women's footwear. She takes a class, turning an object left behind by him into the start of an ambition that belongs to her. That change sits beside the more uncertain possibilities of romance. Daniel, played by Harry Connick Jr., is attracted to Holly, but their dinner together exposes how present Gerry remains in her thoughts. Holly's mother Patricia has also been part of the letter deliveries, though she doubts whether the arrangement is helping. These people cannot take over Gerry's place, and their relationships with Holly have to develop under different terms. Making room for a career, a friend or her mother becomes part of the same practical task of living again.
The final letter brings Holly and Patricia's relationship into the open. Patricia explains that Gerry asked her to help organise the messages, and that she could not refuse him even while worrying about the effect on her daughter. Her own experience of being left to raise children helps explain her anger and fear. Holly later shares Gerry's last message with Daniel at Yankee Stadium. It asks her to see herself through Gerry's loving eyes and to remain open to love. A kiss then settles something between the two living friends: neither feels the romantic connection they had considered. They can keep the friendship without forcing it into another shape. Holly takes Patricia to Ireland, wanting her mother to have a chance to laugh and see the world. There they meet William and his father. William hopes to see Holly again, leaving a possibility rather than a completed new love story.
LaGravenese changed the novel's geography to make the marriage connect New York and Ireland. An earlier screenplay had shifted the story entirely to New York; he returned to Cecelia Ahern's book and brought back more of the letters' practical content. He liked the way Gerry could suggest something as ordinary as buying a bedside lamp, rather than delivering general advice about enjoying life. The opening argument and much of the marriage's particular dynamic came from LaGravenese, while the book's larger family network was reduced. His own loss of a young friend informed the feeling of someone remaining close after death and then, later, seeming farther away. Those choices explain the film's mixture of domestic friction, remembered intimacy and outward adventures. Gerry is allowed to be a husband Holly argued with as well as a person she misses. The letters work through habits and shared jokes, rather than turning him into an impersonal voice of wisdom.
Ahern welcomed the screenplay as another person's interpretation of her story. She distinguished the book she had written from the film LaGravenese was making, placing more weight on its emotional meaning than on preserving every setting or casting choice. She understood why the adaptation reduced Holly's extended family, although she missed the relationships with her brothers. Daniel's personality also changed for the screen. For the author, those departures served the demands of telling the story in a different form. The film consequently builds Holly's circle around a smaller group of recognisable people, giving her friends and mother room to respond to a recovery that is uneven and sometimes frustrating for everyone involved.

