V4mp

Explore V4mp

Find your next route. Get back to playing.

← Back to the film shelf
October: Ten Days That Shook the World poster
V4mp Cinema

October: Ten Days That Shook the World

1927 · Grigori Aleksandrov, Sergei Eisenstein

October: Ten Days That Shook the World follows the Bolsheviks' rise in Petrograd, from the fall of the Tsar to the assault on the Winter Palace. Sergei Eisenstein and Grigori Aleksandrov's silent propaganda drama makes revolutionary crowds, political conflict and the overthrow of the Provisional Government its subjects.

SilentDramaHistoricalPropaganda

Behind the film

Year
1927
Director
Grigori Aleksandrov, Sergei Eisenstein
Writers
Grigori Aleksandrov, Sergei Eisenstein
Genres
Silent, Drama, Historical, Propaganda
Production
Sovkino, Mosfilm
Country
Soviet Union
Cast
Vladimir Uralsky, Eduard Tisse, Vladimir Popov, Boris Livanov, Vasily Nikandrov, Nikolai Podvoisky

About the film

Contains story spoilers.

October begins with a Tsar's monument pulled down, then follows a Provisional Government unable to end war and hunger. Lenin arrives in Petrograd to cheering supporters. July demonstrations meet gunfire, bridges rise to separate workers from the centre, and Bolshevik headquarters are wrecked. Lenin goes into hiding. When General Kornilov advances, the Bolsheviks organise resistance and secure weapons. The struggle moves towards an uprising, with Lenin returning to Smolny and the cruiser Aurora approaching as workers take the bridges. These are staged images made for a revolutionary anniversary. In its 1959 programme, the Museum of Modern Art described the film's approach as a political cartoon, with deliberate omissions and distortions. That distinction matters at the Winter Palace: the assault belongs to a constructed propaganda drama, rather than a film record of the actual 1917 attack.

The scale of that reconstruction depended on access to the city and its people. Shari Kizirian's Senses of Cinema account describes the anniversary commission interrupting work on The General Line. Eisenstein, Aleksandrov and cameraman Eduard Tisse were drawn away from that project to make October. Scriptwriting began in January, and filming started in April in Leningrad, the city formerly called Petrograd. Streets and buildings could therefore play the places they had been during the revolution. Thousands volunteered for the recreated July unrest around Sadovaya Street and Nevsky Prospect. Even the Aurora was made available for filming, bringing the ship itself into the reconstruction. For the arguments at Smolny, the filmmakers drew on John Reed's Ten Days That Shook the World. Kizirian describes a former girls' school filled with representatives debating in close, smoky quarters. Such scenes required crowds who could argue and move together, alongside the large street actions. Historical figures were also cast through physical resemblance: Vasili Nikandrov was chosen to play Lenin. This mixture of locations, volunteers and look-alikes supplied the human and architectural material for the commemorative film.

Lenin's presence does not turn October into a conventional portrait of a leader. Harvard Film Archive's programme note describes him as only briefly glimpsed among soldiers, sailors, student agitators and counterrevolutionaries. Its account places the ensemble ahead of a single protagonist. Kerensky, by contrast, emerges as the most strongly marked individual, embodying the arrogance of the political establishment the film attacks. This uneven distribution of attention helps explain why following one character cannot provide the whole route through the drama. The Archive also describes October as more complex than Battleship Potemkin and less warmly received by audiences. That response exposed Eisenstein to criticism that his work had become excessively intellectual and formalist. The political celebration also became an argument about how a revolutionary film should address its audience.

Eisenstein's own account in Film Form explains how the cuts were meant to make political judgments. Kerensky repeatedly climbs the Winter Palace stairs while intertitles announce increasingly grand ranks. Eisenstein describes the climbing pace as unchanged: the titles rise while the man's action stays the same. The mismatch was designed to make his authority ridiculous. Elsewhere, a tank is joined through editing to a plaster Napoleon on Kerensky's desk, apparently crushing it. Eisenstein calls this a symbolic juxtaposition. The images need not share a continuous physical space for the comparison to attack Kerensky's ambitions.

The religious montage accompanying Kornilov's advance had another declared purpose. Eisenstein says its succession of deity images was intended to unsettle a preconceived idea of God and direct thought as well as emotion. He was less satisfied with the harps intercut with Menshevik speeches, rejecting the comparison as literary rather than dynamically expressive. By contrast, he praised spinning bicycle wheels joined to the arrival of motorcycle delegates for giving their entrance emotional movement. His explanation distinguishes an intended intellectual argument from an effect he later considered unsuccessful. The uprising ends with the Winter Palace stormed and the Provisional Government's ministers arrested. Clocks across the world mark the victory while the Soviets cheer. The final movement turns from taking power to exercising it: the new government passes decrees for peace and land.

Different editions can substantially change the film a viewer encounters. The Berlinale's 2012 restoration programme explains that Eisenstein recut October for export, after which censorship and alterations in different countries produced multiple circulating versions. Its digital restoration used a Munich Film Museum print acquired from Gosfilmofond in the 1970s, supplemented with material from the EYE Instituut in Amsterdam and the Bundesarchiv in Berlin. This was a reconstruction assembled from archival holdings, rather than a simple transfer of one universally definitive print. The accompanying Edmund Meisel music was also reconstructed and adapted specifically to this edition. The programme draws attention to its emphatic rhythms and the use of noises within the orchestration, features that had been controversial. That account concerns this restoration's accompaniment; a different score or screening edition can present a different combination of images and music.

Keep exploring

Meet the editors

Two seats. Two perspectives.

V4mp and Baby Bat.
A shared love of stories, with room for different takes.

V
V4mpFILMS & GAMES

One half of Dead Good Reviews.

B
Baby BatFILMS, BOOKS & GAMES

The curator behind Baby Bat’s Library.