Behind the film
- Year
- 2005
- Director
- Woody Allen
- Writers
- Woody Allen
- Runtime
- 2h 4m
- Genres
- Crime, Drama, Romance
- Production
- BBC Film, The Montecito Picture Company, UK Film Council
- Country
- United Kingdom, United States, Luxembourg
- Cast
- Jonathan Rhys Meyers, Scarlett Johansson, Emily Mortimer, Matthew Goode, Brian Cox, Penelope Wilton, Ewen Bremner, James Nesbitt
About the film
Contains story spoilers.
The opening image gives the film its governing question: a tennis ball catches the top of a net and hangs, for a moment, before it falls on one side. Chris Wilton understands the metaphor because he used to compete as a professional player, though he never reached the wins he expected. In London he teaches tennis at an expensive club, where he meets Tom Hewett, a young member with an inherited ease around money, opera and people who can make introductions. The club is a workplace for Chris and a social world for Tom. Chris moves between them carefully, watching what the family takes for granted and what it can offer him.
Tom invites Chris into the Hewett family’s orbit, where Chloe quickly becomes interested in him. She is warm and attentive, introduces him to her parents and persuades her father to give him a position in the family business. At a gathering there, Chris meets Nola Rice, Tom’s American fiancée and an aspiring actor. Nola is trying to fit into a household where Eleanor Hewett treats her career as an embarrassing uncertainty. When Eleanor criticizes her, Nola leaves the house in a storm; Chris follows, admits his attraction, and the two begin an affair. Nola soon calls it a mistake, but Chris wants to keep seeing her. He is drawn to the person and the excitement, yet he also sees that Chloe’s interest could open a different future.
The split becomes sharper when Tom ends his engagement to Nola after falling for someone else. Chris marries Chloe as his position in her father Alec’s company gives him a respectable career alongside his place in the family. Nola returns to London, and the affair resumes in private. At the same time, Chloe wants a child and Chris remains cool toward the idea, while Nola becomes pregnant and asks him to leave Chloe so they can raise the baby together. He presses her to have an abortion. Nola refuses, and her calls and demands for a decision keep interrupting the comfortable routine Chris has constructed with Chloe: a home, a job and the expectation of social success.
Chris is not simply caught between two relationships. He has chosen the security of the Hewett family and fears the consequences of losing it. When Nola confronts him and threatens to tell Chloe, he decides that protecting his position matters more than either woman’s future. He takes a shotgun from the Hewett household and uses a planned meeting to get access to Nola’s building. First he enters the flat of her elderly neighbour, Mrs Eastby, kills her, and makes the room look as if a burglary has taken place. He waits in the hall, then kills Nola when she arrives. The murders are staged to resemble a robbery and leave the police with an apparently ordinary crime rather than a motive that points back to Chris.
Chris meets Chloe at the theatre after the killings, carrying on as if the night were normal. Before a police interview, he throws the stolen jewellery and medication into the Thames, but Mrs Eastby’s wedding ring strikes the railing and lands on the pavement. Detective Mike Banner has found Nola’s diary, forcing Chris to admit the affair while denying the murders. Later, Nola and Mrs Eastby appear to Chris as accusing apparitions; that night Banner dreams of how Chris committed the crime. The next morning, his partner Dowd reports that a murdered drug addict had Eastby’s ring. Banner even considers that the man could have found the discarded jewellery, but the alternative suspect is enough to derail his theory. The object Chris failed to dispose of helps him escape the inquiry.
The final family scene brings the title’s image back without giving Chris a clean victory. Chloe has had a baby boy, and the family celebrates while Chris stands apart, listening as Tom wishes the child luck. His social ascent has brought him the household, career and security he wanted, at the cost of the two people he killed. Allen originally wrote the story for New York and moved it to London when he found financing there. He described the transition as relatively straightforward, with class distinctions more openly acknowledged in England. The tennis club, the country house and the family company each give Chris another means of belonging. The ring’s unexpected path is the corresponding accident: he can manage his relationships and manufacture an alibi, yet the outcome still depends on something beyond his control.
Opera also gives that comfortable world a more troubling dimension. Chris’s enthusiasm is established before he becomes wealthy, helping him connect with Tom while remaining a private interest of his own. During the double murder, a sustained passage from Verdi’s Otello runs alongside the action, placing another unfolding drama beneath Chris’s movements. The music continues through stretches of waiting and interruption rather than simply changing mood to match each event. That creates a distance between the cultivated tastes Chris shares with the Hewetts and the violence he is carrying out. The film has already shown him reading Crime and Punishment; its final investigation then gives him a different fate from the punishment suggested by that literary association.

