Behind the film
- Year
- 1996
- Director
- Jerry Zaks
- Writers
- John Guare
- Runtime
- 1h 38m
- Genres
- Drama
- Production
- TriBeCa Productions
- Country
- United States
- Cast
- Meryl Streep, Leonardo DiCaprio, Diane Keaton, Robert De Niro, Hume Cronyn, Dan Hedaya, Margo Martindale, Kelly Ripa
About the film
Contains story spoilers.
Marvin's Room brings two estranged sisters back into the same Florida household after years of separate lives. Bessie stayed to care for their bedridden father, Marvin, while Lee moved to Ohio and raised her sons Hank and Charlie. Diane Keaton plays Bessie, with Meryl Streep as Lee and Leonardo DiCaprio as Hank. The reunion arrives when neither household is secure. Hank has been committed to a mental institution after setting fire to his mother's house. An unexpected call from Bessie sends Lee and the boys south, into a home whose routines have continued without them. Returning means meeting relatives the children barely know and confronting the work Lee left behind.
Bessie's diagnosis of leukemia creates the immediate reason for that journey: she needs a compatible bone marrow donor, and her relatives offer a possibility of finding one. The woman who has been attending to everyone else's needs must now ask for help herself. Lee is approaching the end of her cosmetology training and fears losing the independent life she has struggled to establish. Thinking ahead to Marvin's care, she begins considering a nursing home. The tests draw the sisters and boys into a shared medical problem, but they cannot erase the years of distance. Even agreeing to be tested carries an emotional charge for Hank, whose relationship with his mother has already become an open conflict.
Hank gradually forms a connection with Bessie, and the family begins to recover some of the closeness the sisters have lost. That change does not produce the medical rescue they need. Neither boy proves a compatible donor, and Bessie's condition deteriorates. Lee starts to accept that caring for the family will now fall to her. She learns about Marvin's medications and takes lunch into his room, where Bessie is using a mirror to catch the sunlight and make their father smile. The final scene leaves Bessie's illness unresolved. Its immediate resolution is Lee's willingness to enter the room and participate in the ordinary acts of care that have occupied her sister's life.
Scott McPherson's source play grew out of family experience before it acquired its close association with the AIDS epidemic. Roundabout Theatre Company's account of its history traces the material to his childhood, when his widowed mother combined raising children, paid work and caring for her mother, who had cancer. McPherson later watched illness reshape his adult community, including his relationship with cartoonist Daniel Sotomayor. In a program note for the play's Hartford production, he described friends caring for one another as their relative health changed. He completed a screenplay before his death in 1992; the film followed in 1996. That background gives the reversal in Bessie's position a particular context: being a caregiver offers no permanent protection from becoming the person who needs care, and affection has to survive that exchange of roles.
Keaton described the difficulty of playing Bessie's unguarded feelings in her Fresh Air interview. Irony came more naturally to her, and she struggled with the late scene in which Bessie expresses gratitude for having loved other people. Her own imagined response to such frightening medical news would have been panic, making the character's generosity hard to inhabit. Keaton did not consider the writing false; she thought the lines belonged to Bessie and needed help reaching them. Streep encouraged her, and looking into her fellow actor's face helped her through the moment. Director Jerry Zaks also asked her to slow down rather than hurry past the feeling. Keaton's account makes the scene a specific acting problem: she had to stay with an emotion she understood in the character but could not easily imagine accepting herself. Bessie's gratitude required a different rhythm from the quickness and protective humor in which Keaton felt more comfortable.
The conversation between Bessie and Hank outside the doctor's office places that difficulty with listening on a smaller scale. Hank tells her disturbing stories about life in the institution, while she doubts him and thinks he has been inventing tales to upset her. When she follows him outside, he insists that she knows nothing about the place. Bessie offers to listen, then recalls being frightened and bored during her own hospital stay. Their exchange keeps slipping between an attempt to connect and renewed suspicion. The scene makes room for awkwardness between two people who need something from each other; sympathy does not arrive as an effortless quality either can simply decide to possess.
The film's stage origins leave much of its force with the ensemble and the pressure between people sharing a house. Time Out's review described Zaks as relying on the actors rather than extensively opening out McPherson's text, singling out Streep's working-class credibility and Keaton's mixture of vulnerability with modest acts of courage. The same account regarded the photography as discreet and Rachel Portman's score as a gentle accompaniment to the melodrama. That reading treats the performances as the means of giving familiar family roles some particularity. Edward Guthmann's contemporary review likewise praised the cast's willingness to play intimate feelings without hiding behind irony. He saw Streep's Lee as angry and frustrated while remaining lonely and ashamed, rather than simply a selfish obstacle to Bessie's goodness. Between those responses and Keaton's account of the final gratitude scene, the sisters' conflict depends on allowing both women to remain emotionally recognizable.

