Behind the film
- Year
- 2011
- Director
- Will Gluck
- Writers
- Will Gluck
- Runtime
- 1h 49m
- Genres
- Comedy, Romance, Romantic comedy
- Production
- Screen Gems, Castle Rock Entertainment
- Country
- United States
- Cast
- Mila Kunis, Justin Timberlake, Patricia Clarkson, Jenna Elfman, Richard Jenkins, Woody Harrelson, Emma Stone, Bryan Greenberg
About the film
Contains story spoilers.
Jamie Rellis is a New York headhunter who approaches Dylan Harper, an art director in Los Angeles, about taking a job at GQ. Dylan is fresh from a breakup and tired of emotional entanglements; Jamie has also been hurt and is wary of the tidy promises in romantic comedies. She brings him to New York to interview and, on a night out that includes a flash mob in Times Square, persuades him that the city and the job are worth the move. Dylan accepts a one-year contract, and Jamie earns a commission. The two become friends, with a shared joke about the genre conventions they claim to reject. That joke gives them language for avoiding vulnerability even as they get closer.
When they decide to have sex without calling it a relationship, they lay out rules as if clear terms can prevent feelings. Their friendship gives the arrangement a comfortable base: Jamie and Dylan can speak openly, laugh at the romantic-comedy scenes they watch together and return to their separate lives afterwards. The plan works until Jamie starts dating again. She meets Parker, a paediatric oncologist, and follows her five-date rule before sleeping with him. Parker ends things the next morning. The breakup leaves Jamie angry and embarrassed, and Dylan offers to take her to California for the Fourth of July rather than leave her alone with it. Jamie initially resists, then goes because she trusts him as a friend.
In Los Angeles, Jamie meets Dylan’s sister Annie, his nephew Sam and his father, who is in the early stages of Alzheimer’s disease. Dylan’s family gives Jamie a view of the life that exists outside their banter and the job that brought him east. She and Dylan tell his relatives that they are only friends, but they sleep together again. The next day, Jamie overhears Dylan speaking to Annie. He says Jamie is too damaged for him to date. She hears the sentence as proof that he considers her unfit for a real relationship. She flies back to New York and stops answering his calls. When Dylan finds her on the rooftop she had shown him when they first met, Jamie tells him what she heard and ends both their friendship and their casual arrangement.
The break does not clear the air. Later, Jamie learns Dylan may leave GQ before his contract is finished, which would affect the commission she earned for recruiting him. She confronts him, and the professional detail brings their personal anger back to the surface. At the same time, Jamie spends time with her mother, Lorna, whose unplanned choices and free-spirited style have long been a source of frustration. Dylan accompanies his father to Newark airport. During a confused moment, his father mistakes a passerby for a woman he once loved. When he becomes lucid again, he tells Dylan about the relationship he let go and the regret that stayed with him. The story gives Dylan a family memory to hear rather than a clever line to hide behind.
His father’s story makes Dylan consider what he is about to lose. He calls Lorna and arranges for Jamie to go to Grand Central, where he stages a second flash mob. The first one had helped get Dylan to New York; this one is his attempt to tell Jamie that he wants her in his life for more than sex and friendship. He catches up to her in the station and admits how he feels. Jamie, surprised by the gesture, kisses him. They walk to the Pershing Square café across the street, where they try to treat the moment as a first date but quickly fall back into their physical closeness. The film ends with them beginning a relationship under different terms, although the familiar romantic-comedy ending is now something they have both chosen rather than something they said they were above.
Jamie’s mother and Dylan’s father help the pair see different versions of love. Lorna has her own life and rarely conforms to Jamie’s expectations; Dylan’s father has a memory that comes and goes, but his regret about a woman from his past remains clear. The characters’ families complicate their positions without turning the story into a family drama. Jamie’s closeness to Lorna and Dylan’s concern for his father are part of the lives they have brought into their friendship. Gluck developed the dialogue with Kunis and Timberlake by working through twenty pages at a time, reading them aloud and rewriting before moving on. Their exchanges grew through that practical process, giving the arguments and flirtation the same familiar voices.
Their conversations during sex follow the same frank, practical approach: they can tell each other what feels right or wrong without worrying about hurting romantic feelings. Talking about commitment proves much harder. The film also gives them a sentimental movie to watch and mock together, with Jason Segel and Rashida Jones playing its lovers. Jamie knows its dialogue even while criticising its promises. Her affection for that invented romance complicates her claim that she wants nothing like it herself.

