V4mp

Explore V4mp

Find your next route. Get back to playing.

← Back to the film shelf
Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close poster
V4mp Cinema

Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close

2011 · 2h 9m · Stephen Daldry

After his father dies in the September 11 attacks, nine-year-old Oskar Schell finds a key in a vase and searches New York for the lock it opens. His journey through the city brings him into contact with strangers, an elusive grandfather and the mother he has shut out, while he carries guilt over the last call he did not answer.

Coming-of-ageDrama

Behind the film

Year
2011
Director
Stephen Daldry
Writers
Eric Roth
Runtime
2h 9m
Genres
Coming-of-age, Drama
Production
Paramount Pictures, Scott Rudin Productions, Warner Bros. Entertainment
Country
United States
Cast
Thomas Horn, Max von Sydow, Sandra Bullock, Viola Davis, Tom Hanks, John Goodman, Jeffrey Wright, Zoe Caldwell

About the film

Contains story spoilers.

On September 11, 2001, nine-year-old Oskar Schell comes home from school to find messages from his father, Thomas, calling from the World Trade Center. He hides beneath his bed as his grandmother tries to comfort him. The film does not show Thomas escaping; the calls end as the towers fall. Oskar keeps the answering machine and its recordings secret, along with the memory of the final call he could not bring himself to answer. At the funeral, the empty casket makes the loss feel impossible to grasp. In the year that follows, he pulls away from his mother, Linda, and returns to the objects and routines that still connect him to his father.

Thomas had made their relationship a series of explorations. He encouraged Oskar’s curiosity and devised treasure hunts that required him to approach strangers, turning the city into a puzzle and a way to practice the social encounters that frighten him. Oskar is precise, intelligent and easily overwhelmed by noise, touch and crowds. When he accidentally breaks a vase in Thomas’s closet, a small envelope falls out. It contains a key and the name “Black.” Oskar assumes his father left him a clue and decides that finding the matching lock will reveal what Thomas meant to tell him. The search gives grief a concrete task, even as it keeps him from speaking openly about what happened.

Oskar searches a phone book and finds hundreds of New Yorkers named Black. He begins visiting them one by one, usually telling Linda that he is going elsewhere. He records the encounters in a scrapbook, noting details about the people and the city as he moves through neighborhoods and across boroughs. The Blacks have different backgrounds and circumstances; most listen to him, although none can identify the lock. His first important lead, Abby Black, is separating from her husband and does not recognize the key. The repeated failures do not stop Oskar, because the effort itself resembles the exploratory games Thomas once set for him. Yet his secrecy turns the search into another wall between him and Linda.

During one visit to his grandmother’s apartment, Oskar meets her quiet boarder, an elderly man who communicates by writing and with “yes” and “no” tattooed on his palms. Oskar calls him “the renter.” The two begin making the rounds together. The renter’s presence helps Oskar cross bridges, ride public transport and enter unfamiliar places, while the older man’s silences keep his own history at a distance. Oskar gradually suspects that he is his grandfather, the father Thomas had long been estranged from. Their outings become a second kind of search: Oskar is learning how to move through the city, and the renter is being drawn back toward the family from which he withdrew.

Oskar eventually plays the answering-machine messages for the renter. The recordings become harder to hear as Thomas’s calls grow more urgent. The older man asks him to stop the tape before its final message, but Oskar presses on, wanting to recover the words he missed. The scene makes his guilt plain without resolving it: he was a child, alone and terrified, and could not answer. Later, Oskar sees the renter arguing with his grandmother and packing to leave. He tries to reach him as a taxi pulls away, telling him that he knows who he is. The renter’s departure leaves Oskar facing both the father he has lost and the grandfather he has only just found.

A telephone number on a newspaper clipping leads Oskar back to Abby, who takes him to meet her former husband, William. William recognizes the key: it belonged to his own father, who had sold the vase to Thomas without knowing the key was inside. There is no hidden message from Thomas, only an accidental chain of ownership. Oskar tells William that he was at home when the sixth call came and did not pick up. He leaves the key with him and runs away, disappointed that the object has not yielded the answer he wanted and shaken by the confession he has finally made. The search has reached its literal end, but it has not erased the loss or his memory of that day.

Back home, Oskar starts destroying the materials from his search. Linda stops him and tells him she knew about his visits. She had gone ahead to meet the Blacks and prepare them for Oskar, following his progress while letting him believe he was alone. Oskar writes to the people he met, thanking them for their kindness, and asks his grandfather to return. The renter comes back to live with Oskar’s grandmother. Oskar gives Linda the scrapbook he made from the search, with pop-ups and pull-tabs, and names it after the film. Soon afterward, he goes to Central Park, where he and Thomas used to spend time, and looks beneath his father’s favorite swing. He finds a message Thomas left there, congratulating him for completing their final expedition. The film ends with Oskar on the swing.

Keep exploring

Meet the editors

Two seats. Two perspectives.

V4mp and Baby Bat.
A shared love of stories, with room for different takes.

V
V4mpFILMS & GAMES

One half of Dead Good Reviews.

B
Baby BatFILMS, BOOKS & GAMES

The curator behind Baby Bat’s Library.