Behind the film
- Year
- 1986
- Director
- Jim Jarmusch
- Writers
- Jim Jarmusch
- Runtime
- 1h 47m
- Genres
- Buddy, Comedy, Prison, Independent
- Production
- PolyGram Filmed Entertainment
- Country
- United States, Germany
- Cast
- Tom Waits, John Lurie, Roberto Benigni, Nicoletta Braschi, Ellen Barkin, Rockets Redglare, Vernel Bagneris, Joy N. Houck, Jr.
About the film
Contains story spoilers, including the ending.
Down by Law puts Zack, a New Orleans disc jockey, and Jack, a pimp, in the same prison cell after separate set-ups. Tom Waits plays Zack, whose agreement to drive a car across town ends when the police discover a body in its boot. John Lurie plays Jack, drawn into a police trap by another hustler. Their shared circumstances do little to make them friends. Roberto Benigni's arrival as an Italian prisoner brings an entirely different manner into the room. He collects English expressions in a notebook and admits that he killed a man during a card game, claiming self-defence. His delight in words interrupts the two Americans' hostility. A chant about ice cream spreads beyond their cell, turning an idle phrase into a brief communal performance. Roberto eventually proposes the escape that carries all three men into the bayou.
Jim Jarmusch wrote and directed the film with a simple situation in mind: people who dislike one another forced to remain together. Prison gave him a direct way to bring that about. The Louisiana setting began with his interest in New Orleans blues and rhythm and blues, before he had actually visited the city. Another starting point was his friendship with Benigni, whom he met while serving on a festival jury in Italy. They had no shared fluent language and communicated through gestures and imperfect French. Some of Roberto's unlikely English expressions came from a magazine Benigni had used to learn the language. Their earlier conversations therefore fed into a character who can connect with others despite his limited vocabulary. Jarmusch also resisted dubbing the film for its Italian release. He regarded an actor's voice as a major part of a performance, and changing it would remove something the actor had contributed. In a film built around three conspicuously different ways of speaking, that choice keeps the friction and curiosity between them audible.
Robby Müller's black-and-white photography gives the journey a visual continuity from the streets through the rural landscape. The opening tracking shots establish a Louisiana world before the prison walls narrow it to the men and their arguments. After the escape, movement does not immediately settle their problems: the bayou offers more room while leaving them dependent on one another. The film gives attention to those relationships rather than making the mechanics of the break its central attraction. Waits and Lurie brought musical careers as well as their screen presence to the production, and Lurie composed the score. Waits had already worked in films, including writing the songs for Francis Ford Coppola's One from the Heart. Here the two musicians play men whose self-presentation repeatedly collides with Benigni's unpredictable friendliness. The supporting cast includes Ellen Barkin as Zack's girlfriend, Billie Neal as Jack's partner and Nicoletta Braschi as the woman Roberto meets later. Their encounters place the prisoners' exaggerated ideas about themselves beside people who have their own demands and lives.
Jarmusch sought a New Orleans made from neighbourhood details rather than a tour of familiar landmarks. He spoke of wooden balcony railings, empty pavements and particular views along streets as things that belonged to the city's atmosphere. Production designer Janet Densmore helped him find locations and props that matched what he wanted. Two early scenes used corners in the Faubourg Marigny: one where Zack's discarded clothes spill into the street, and another near an old petrol station where he meets Roberto and the man who offers him the driving job. The film moves from those streets and rooms to prison, then to the surrounding bayous. An accidental change of language also stayed in it. Benigni had been meant to describe a song as sad and beautiful, but kept saying world instead. Jarmusch felt that the mistaken word fitted New Orleans and the story. Roberto's imperfect speech thus supplies a phrase broader than the one originally intended, while still sounding like something this particular visitor might say.
Freedom gives the three men somewhere to go without making Zack and Jack more certain of themselves. After the swamps, they find a restaurant run by Nicoletta, another Italian living far from home. Roberto's immediate connection with her gives him a reason to remain. The two Americans borrow clothes from the household and prepare to continue their journeys, leaving the new couple behind. Nicoletta tells them that a fork in the road will lead in opposite directions, but she cannot identify which branch goes where. The sign they expect is absent. Their final choice is therefore made without the reassurance of knowing that either road will deliver the future they want. Earlier, Roberto's interest in Robert Frost's poetry has introduced the image of diverging paths; the ending gives that image a physical place. Zack and Jack take separate routes, while Roberto has found somewhere to stop. Their escape has changed the setting and loosened the forced partnership, but the film leaves their destinations beyond the point where they part.

