V4mp

Explore V4mp

Find your next route. Get back to playing.

← Back to the film shelf
Crimes and Misdemeanors poster
V4mp Cinema

Crimes and Misdemeanors

1989 · 1h 40m · Woody Allen

A respected eye doctor fears that his mistress will expose their affair and his financial wrongdoing. Across New York, a struggling documentary filmmaker accepts work from a brother-in-law he despises. Their separate troubles bring murder, jealousy and questions of conscience together when the two men meet at a family wedding.

ComedyDramaCrime

Behind the film

Year
1989
Director
Woody Allen
Writers
Woody Allen
Runtime
1h 40m
Genres
Comedy, Drama, Crime
Production
Jack Rollins & Charles H. Joffe Productions
Country
United States
Cast
Martin Landau, Mia Farrow, Alan Alda, Anjelica Huston, Jerry Orbach, Joanna Gleason, Woody Allen, Claire Bloom

About the film

Contains story spoilers, including the ending.

Crimes and Misdemeanors follows two New Yorkers whose private troubles threaten the lives they think they deserve. Martin Landau plays Judah Rosenthal, a wealthy ophthalmologist with a family and a respected public position. His mistress, Dolores Paley, wants him to leave his wife and threatens to reveal both their affair and his misuse of charitable money. Woody Allen plays Cliff Stern, a documentary filmmaker who regards his work as more serious than the successful television career of his brother-in-law Lester. Judah's concern is protecting the comfortable life he already has. Cliff hopes to secure a different one through his work and a new relationship. Their stories run alongside each other until a wedding brings the two men into conversation. Judah's decisions lead to a killing, while Cliff's disappointment grows out of his feelings about success, integrity and the woman he loves.

Judah begins by presenting himself as a generous man at a banquet held in his honour. His account of his father's religious teaching connects his profession to the idea of being watched by God. Once Dolores threatens to reach his wife, however, he looks for ways to silence her. His brother Jack has criminal connections and offers a means of removing the threat altogether. Judah reacts with horror, even as the conversation supplies the solution he eventually accepts. The story keeps returning to his need to explain himself: he fears the destruction of his family life, imagines moral arguments and tries to understand whether he can live with the result. Sven Nykvist's cinematography accompanies these conversations in sustained takes, allowing the characters' changing positions to unfold within a scene. The parallel story has its own unease beneath Cliff's jokes. His resentment of Lester includes professional rivalry and an assumption that worthwhile work should bring the recognition that commercial success has failed to give him.

Landau described playing Judah as a problem of keeping the audience close to a man whose actions offer no redemption. He needed the whole screenplay to understand the part and was given it to read after meeting Allen in New York. Before that meeting, he had prepared by reading eight of Allen's other scripts. His task was to make Judah recognisable as a person while letting the horror of his behaviour remain. The distinction between what Judah knows and what other people know also affected the performances around him. Landau recalled that Claire Bloom, playing Miriam, had read her own scenes and understood the couple as happy, with her husband troubled by business difficulties. Anjelica Huston was not given the same knowledge of Judah's home life. Those separate perspectives suit the relationships he maintains: his wife sees a worried husband, while Dolores sees someone who has repeatedly failed to give her the future he promised. Landau described creating inner unrest and then having the character attempt to conceal it, rather than openly displaying every feeling to the people around him.

Huston found Dolores a departure from the forceful, threatening women she was often expected to play. Here she was a flight attendant whose need for Judah had left her grasping for a commitment he would not make. The costume and hair helped create that unfamiliar figure; Huston recalled seeing herself with Farrah Fawcett-style bangs and an argyle sweater before going on set. Dolores's demand is specific. She wants Judah to honour a shared future, while he wants their relationship to disappear without damaging his marriage or standing.

The film's questions about conscience do not produce equal consequences for its characters. Judah initially suffers after the murder, but eventually resumes his comfortable life. Cliff's belief in his own standards does not protect him from disappointment. Discussing the wedding conversation years later, Allen said that people can commit terrible crimes, escape punishment and continue to enjoy their families. Others remain troubled by guilt, and he rejected the idea that the world reliably distributes either response according to what someone deserves. Rabbi Ben and Professor Louis Levy give the story other ways of approaching that uncertainty. Ben's faith supports him as he loses his sight. Levy's recorded statements offer Cliff an account of love and meaning, yet the professor's suicide prevents those words from becoming a simple promise that their speaker could always live by. Their presence leaves the viewer listening to convictions that have very different relationships to each character's actual experience.

Cliff takes the job of filming Lester to support his documentary about Levy and grows close to associate producer Halley Reed. His hostile cut of Lester's portrait gets him fired. Levy dies, Halley leaves for London, and Cliff later discovers at the wedding that she and Lester are engaged. Judah enters the adjoining room where Cliff has withdrawn and describes his own crime as an idea for a story. He explains that the killer's guilt diminished and his prosperity continued. Cliff proposes an ending in which the man confesses, accepting responsibility even without divine justice. Judah leaves with Miriam, keeping his secret inside the apparently fictional account. The final passage brings back Levy's voice over Ben dancing with his daughter and images from the film. His words concern the choices that define people and the meaning they make through love in an indifferent universe. The wedding therefore places ordinary family happiness alongside knowledge of what Judah has done, without turning his conversation with Cliff into a confession to the police.

Keep exploring

Meet the editors

Two seats. Two perspectives.

V4mp and Baby Bat.
A shared love of stories, with room for different takes.

V
V4mpFILMS & GAMES

One half of Dead Good Reviews.

B
Baby BatFILMS, BOOKS & GAMES

The curator behind Baby Bat’s Library.