V4mp

Explore V4mp

Find your next route. Get back to playing.

← Back to the film shelf
Capote poster
V4mp Cinema

Capote

2005 · 1h 50m · Bennett Miller

After a Kansas family is murdered, Truman Capote travels with Harper Lee to investigate for The New Yorker. His interviews draw him toward Perry Smith, one of the convicted killers, and a book that depends on Smith’s account and the outcome of his appeals.

BiographicalDramaCrimeLgbtq-related

Behind the film

Year
2005
Director
Bennett Miller
Writers
Dan Futterman
Runtime
1h 50m
Genres
Biographical, Drama, Crime, Lgbtq-related
Country
Canada, United States
Cast
Philip Seymour Hoffman, Catherine Keener, Clifton Collins, Chris Cooper, Bruce Greenwood, Bob Balaban, Amy Ryan, Mark Pellegrino

About the film

Contains story spoilers.

In 1959, Truman Capote is a celebrated New York writer, moving among parties and editors while looking for a nonfiction subject. A short newspaper report about the Clutter family murders in Holcomb, Kansas, gives him one. He calls William Shawn at The New Yorker, then travels west with his childhood friend Nelle Harper Lee. Capote tells investigator Alvin Dewey that he wants to record the town’s reaction but does not care whether the killers are caught. Dewey does care and sends the writer away. The mismatch between Capote’s city manner and the guarded farming community shapes his first days of reporting.

Lee helps Capote make introductions he cannot manage alone. She approaches Laura Kinney, whose friend Nancy Clutter was among the victims, while Capote puts the teenager at ease by describing how people misread his appearance and voice. Laura lends him Nancy’s diary. Dewey’s wife, Marie, invites the pair to dinner; Capote wins her over with stories, then speaks about his own family in a way that moves Dewey. The investigator lets them see crime-scene photographs. They show the killers’ brutality alongside small gestures of care: a pillow beneath one child’s head and another victim tucked into bed. The images complicate Capote’s first impressions of the crime.

Capote and Lee continue interviewing locals, relying on memory rather than notes or a recorder. News arrives that Perry Smith and Richard “Dick” Hickock have been caught in Las Vegas. Capote visits Perry, who is suspicious but drawn to his visitor’s attention. Perry talks about the poor legal advice he and Dick have received. Capote tells Shawn he has enough material for a book, not simply a magazine article, and says Perry’s loneliness and hunger for approval have stayed with him. His project now depends on access to two men whose case may end in execution.

After the trial, Smith and Hickock are convicted and sentenced to death. Capote promises to find them a lawyer for an appeal. He tells friends that his book will restore Perry’s humanity and show what happens when two different Americas collide. Returning to prison, he learns Perry has stopped eating and helps nurse him back to health. They share accounts of painful childhoods, and Perry gives him his diaries. A lawyer Capote secures wins a stay of execution, giving the writer more time with his subject. Perry hopes the book will help his defence, but Capote conceals both his progress and his chosen title, In Cold Blood. He calls Perry a “gold mine” when speaking to Nelle. The kindness that earns Perry’s trust also supplies material for a book Perry has not been allowed to understand.

For a time, Capote leaves Kansas to work in Spain with his partner, Jack Dunphy. He finishes the first half of the manuscript, but tells Shawn that he cannot complete it until he learns what happened during the murders and knows how the legal case will end. When an appeal is denied, he returns to Perry and conceals how much he has written. A New York reading brings applause, and Shawn urges him to finish. Capote is pleased, but the book still lacks its central account. As appeals continue, he grows impatient; Perry begins to see through the friendly performance and asks what the book is really called.

Capote finally tells Perry that his visits have been driven by the missing account of the killings. Perry confronts him with a newspaper report of the reading, and Capote persuades him to explain the night the Clutters died. The film reveals the murders through Perry’s recollection late in the story rather than opening with the crime. Another appeal delays the executions, and Perry sends a telegram asking Capote to find a lawyer. Capote does not act. At a party with Nelle, he calls the postponements torture, exposing how the waiting has become both a personal strain and the condition he needs for his ending.

When the final appeal is rejected, the executions are set for 14 April 1965. Capote stays in his hotel room and refuses to go to the prison, even as Perry asks for him. Nelle phones and reads him Perry’s telegram of forgiveness. He arrives with only minutes to speak to the condemned men, then stands with Dewey and the other witnesses as they are hanged. Afterwards he calls Nelle and says he could not have saved them. She replies that he did not want to. On the plane home, he turns through Perry’s diary and studies a drawing Perry made of him. The book has its ending, but the portrait leaves him looking at himself through the eyes of the man he used.

Bennett Miller keeps much of Capote’s private turmoil beneath the conversations. Philip Seymour Hoffman has to convey the distance between the entertaining public figure and the man whose feelings he cannot explain honestly, even to himself. Miller described designing the images, editing and score to make small changes in the performance matter. Dan Futterman’s screenplay gives Nelle and Jack opportunities to challenge Capote, while allowing long stretches in which he controls how other people see him. His affection for Perry and ambition for the book coexist; the film lets a reassuring prison visit serve both motives. The restrained presentation makes those encounters the centre of the drama, rather than turning the investigation into a hunt for an unknown killer.

Keep exploring

Meet the editors

Two seats. Two perspectives.

V4mp and Baby Bat.
A shared love of stories, with room for different takes.

V
V4mpFILMS & GAMES

One half of Dead Good Reviews.

B
Baby BatFILMS, BOOKS & GAMES

The curator behind Baby Bat’s Library.