Behind the film
- Year
- 2023
- Director
- Justine Triet
- Writers
- Arthur Harari, Justine Triet
- Genres
- Thriller, Crime, Drama, Trial
- Production
- Les Films Pelléas, Les Films de Pierre
- Country
- France
- Cast
- Sandra Hüller, Swann Arlaud, Milo Machado-Graner, Antoine Reinartz, Samuel Theis, Jehnny Beth, Camille Rutherford, Anne Rotger
About the film
Contains story spoilers.
Anatomy of a Fall begins with a conversation that cannot quite happen. Sandra Voyter, a successful German novelist living with her French husband Samuel and their visually impaired son Daniel in an isolated chalet in the Alps, is being interviewed by a student. Samuel’s loud music interrupts them, and the interview ends early. Daniel goes outside with Snoop, the family dog. When he returns, Samuel is dead in the snow below an upper window. The film gives no view of the fall itself. Sandra says she was asleep; the physical evidence does not settle whether Samuel fell, jumped or was pushed. The case turns a household’s private tensions into a public question before anyone can agree on what happened.
The investigation quickly discovers that the family has been living with strains that resist a clean explanation. Samuel had been trying to write, while Sandra’s books had brought her greater success. He resented the time she spent working and accused her of using his ideas; she says he made their life difficult and that his criticism could be cruel. Their son’s partial loss of sight after an accident has also shaped the marriage, with Samuel blaming himself. Sandra tells her lawyer Vincent that Samuel once attempted suicide by taking too much aspirin. That claim could explain his death, but it also makes every disagreement and every account of the past look like evidence for one side or the other. The people around Sandra keep reconstructing the marriage from fragments.
At trial, the language between Sandra and the court becomes another obstacle. She is German, Samuel was French, and the couple often used English at home as a shared language; now she must defend herself in French. Her choices of words and her reserve can be treated as signs of calculation, even when they may reflect fatigue or the difficulty of translating an intimate life into legal answers. Prosecutors examine her relationship with Samuel, her writing and her earlier affair with a woman. Daniel is left to hear adults argue over his parents’ character, before spending the final weekend apart from Sandra so his testimony cannot be shaped by her. The inquiry becomes a contest over who has the right to tell the story of a marriage after one partner can no longer answer. An interpreter can carry the words across the room, but not the tone or history that made them matter inside the marriage.
The central piece of recorded evidence is a violent argument between Sandra and Samuel from the day before his death. The film shows this one sustained flashback while the recording plays in court; it is the closest thing the audience gets to see the couple alone together. Samuel says Sandra has taken his ideas and his time, and the two attack each other with old grievances. Sandra’s anger is real, but the sequence does not settle whether it grew into violence that caused his death. Earlier testimony about a bruise on her wrist now sits beside the recording, and the prosecution uses the quarrel to give motive and shape to a theory of murder. By letting one document stand in for a much longer shared life, the film makes viewers hear the same evidence and still draw different conclusions.
Daniel has to decide what he believes while the case makes him a witness against the person he still lives with. He remembers that after Samuel’s earlier overdose, Snoop became ill. Away from Sandra for a weekend, Daniel deliberately gives the dog aspirin and watches the reaction, trying to test whether Snoop could have eaten Samuel’s vomit on that earlier occasion. The experiment appears to support Sandra’s account, but it does not prove what happened at the chalet. Daniel also tells the court about a conversation with his father on the way to the vet: Samuel spoke about how Daniel would have to go on after losing someone he loved. Daniel once thought he meant the dog; now he hears the words as a warning about himself. No one else heard that private conversation, and the film leaves its reliability open.
Sandra is acquitted, and the legal question closes without resolving the private one. The court has accepted Daniel’s account, but the film has shown how much he wants to make sense of his parents’ conflict and how little anyone can know from the evidence left behind. He and Sandra meet again at home, both wary of the reunion. Their embrace does not return them to the family life they had before Samuel died; instead, it marks their decision to continue together under the weight of what Daniel has heard and said. Sandra later curls up beside Snoop. The dog has been a witness no one can question, while Daniel has had to choose a version of events he can live with. The final image offers comfort and companionship, not a solution to the mystery.

