Behind the film
- Year
- 1996
- Director
- Joel Schumacher
- Writers
- Akiva Goldsman
- Genres
- Crime, Trial, Drama, Thriller
- Production
- Regency Enterprises, Warner Bros. Entertainment
- Country
- United States
- Cast
- Sandra Bullock, Samuel L. Jackson, Matthew McConaughey, Kevin Spacey, Ashley Judd, Donald Sutherland, Oliver Platt, Kiefer Sutherland
About the film
Contains story spoilers, including the ending.
A Time to Kill centres on Carl Lee Hailey's decision to trust Jake Brigance with his defence as racial hostility surrounds their case. Samuel L. Jackson plays Carl Lee, Matthew McConaughey plays Jake, and Sandra Bullock plays Ellen Roark, who offers the young lawyer help. The danger reaches beyond the courtroom: threats force Jake's family to leave town, while Carl Lee continues to place his confidence in him. Joel Schumacher directed the 1996 adaptation of John Grisham's novel, with a screenplay by Akiva Goldsman. The lawyer must continue working while the case makes his own household vulnerable.
Carl Lee is tried in Clanton, Mississippi, after killing the men who attacked his daughter Tonya. A deputy is also wounded in the shooting. Prosecutor Rufus Buckley seeks the death penalty, and Jake cannot secure a change of venue that might produce a more diverse jury. His defence draws on Ellen, Harry Rex Vonner and former mentor Lucien Wilbanks, while the Ku Klux Klan pursues a campaign of intimidation. Ellen is attacked and Jake's house is burned. Discredited psychiatric testimony weakens his case, and Jake urges Carl Lee to consider a plea that would avoid execution. Carl Lee refuses. He tells Jake that his position as a white man gives him knowledge of how the jury thinks. Jake's closing argument asks the jurors to imagine Tonya as white. They acquit Carl Lee, and Sheriff Ozzie Walls arrests men involved in the Klan's crimes. Jake later brings his wife and daughter to the Hailey family's cookout. Their presence answers Carl Lee's earlier doubt that the families' children would ever play together.
Grisham recalled waiting to sell the film rights until he knew which studio and director would make A Time to Kill. Schumacher had directed The Client, and their conversations gave the novelist confidence in his approach. Grisham could read Goldsman's screenplay and offer comments, and he remembered the filmmakers being receptive when he questioned details. His contract also allowed him to veto casting for several leading characters. That became a real obstacle when preparations were already under way and Jake remained uncast. Grisham rejected proposed actors, lawyers became involved, and Schumacher suggested testing McConaughey, whom he knew from Dazed and Confused. Grisham and his wife watched the tape at home. He remembered McConaughey's Texas accent and confident bearing as reasons the test persuaded them, then phoned Schumacher to approve the choice. His account describes a novelist actively involved in deciding who would carry the courtroom story on screen. He also recalled the production using Canton, Mississippi, for Clanton, while making clear that the real town had not been the basis for his fictional town.
Jackson approached Carl Lee as an affectionate family man, a choice he discussed through the scene in which he surrenders to Sheriff Walls. He imagined a father who would gather his children, embrace them and explain that he had to go to jail. That understanding gave him a way to play a man leaving his household with someone he had known for years. Jackson described Charles S. Dutton as an actor whose theatre experience made working together easy. Their shared background helped the surrender depend on familiarity between the two men rather than an elaborate display of force. Jackson also acknowledged that he had filmed more material than appeared in the finished feature. Some of it included moments he particularly wanted to keep, but he recognised that Schumacher had to select the scenes that moved the story in the intended direction. In Jackson's imagined farewell, Carl Lee asks his sons to look after their mother and sister while he is away. He expects to return, and that expectation gives the scene a different feeling from a final goodbye.
McConaughey remembered initially meeting Schumacher about the Klan member eventually played by Kiefer Sutherland. Having read the book, he asked whether Jake had been cast and put himself forward for that role. Schumacher was amused and initially dismissed the possibility, then called him back for an audition. The director's warning that it was unlikely to lead anywhere did not stop McConaughey taking the opportunity. Several weeks later, while he was working on John Sayles's Lone Star, Schumacher offered him Jake. The part therefore emerged from a conversation about a different character in the same film.
Schumacher also worked to make McConaughey familiar before audiences encountered him as Jake. A contemporary report described the director speaking enthusiastically about him to columnist Liz Smith, arranging a screening of the unfinished film for New York media figures and telling journalists about the screen test. A Vanity Fair cover followed the screening. The publicity addressed the studio's concern about placing an unfamiliar actor at the centre of a major Grisham adaptation. The Mississippi setting also left physical traces: a university archive exhibition included a mock University of Mississippi diploma used in A Time to Kill. That exhibition records Canton as a filming location, placing a surviving prop alongside the local history of the adaptation.

