Behind the film
- Year
- 1985
- Director
- Jack Sholder
- Writers
- David Chaskin
- Runtime
- 1h 22m
- Genres
- Horror, Teen, Lgbtq-related, Slasher
- Production
- New Line Cinema's House of Horror
- Country
- United States
- Cast
- Mark Patton, Kim Myers, Robert Rusler, Clu Gulager, Hope Lange, Robert Englund, Marshall Bell, Lyman Ward
About the film
Contains story spoilers, including the ending.
A Nightmare on Elm Street 2: Freddy's Revenge puts Freddy inside the teenager who should be escaping him. Jesse Walsh moves into the former Thompson house with his family and begins having disturbing dreams. The home grows unnaturally hot, ordinary appliances become threatening, and his parents struggle to understand what is happening to him. Lisa helps him investigate the house's connection to Freddy Krueger. Jesse's fear grows when the killing of his gym teacher, Coach Schneider, seems to implicate his own body. Later he goes to his friend Grady and asks him to stay awake. When Grady falls asleep, Jesse's body tears open and Freddy emerges. Grady is killed, leaving Jesse with blood and an experience he cannot explain away. Help from another teenager has become another opportunity for the killer to get out.
Lisa continues trying to reach Jesse even when Freddy takes his place. She appeals to the person she believes is still inside him. Freddy's burned exterior falls away and Jesse returns. The apparent rescue lasts only until the closing school-bus scene. Jesse, Lisa and her friend Kerry are aboard when Jesse recognises details from his earlier nightmares. Freddy's bladed hand bursts through Kerry's chest, and the bus leaves the road as Jesse and Lisa scream. The coda withdraws any certainty that the factory confrontation has made them safe. Jesse has escaped one physical transformation, but the film ends with the threat of another nightmare taking over ordinary life.
Director Jack Sholder inherited an unusually short preparation period. He recalled being offered the sequel about six weeks before its scheduled start, after Wes Craven had left the project. Sholder initially hesitated because he feared becoming confined to horror work, particularly sequels. Accepting meant casting, finding locations and working out pages of effects he did not yet know how to achieve. New Line's instructions were to keep Freddy frightening and dark. Sholder dealt with the pressure by planning the shots in detail, and said his nerves settled when filming began. His later description of the story centres on adolescent sexual anxiety. That reading places Jesse's troubled relationship with his body beside his fear of the killer. It also explains why possession, rather than simply being hunted in a dream, carries so much of this sequel's action.
The order of the scares changed during editing. Sholder felt that the screenplay allowed Freddy to make threats for too long before carrying them out. Producer Robert Shaye wanted a killing moved earlier, but Sholder initially thought the change would break the story's logic. Tightening scenes and adding music did not solve the underlying problem. After an invited horror fan found a screening insufficiently frightening, Sholder worked out a way to bring the coach's death forward and add dialogue to account for it. He remembered solving the problem on his subway journey home. A later screening produced a stronger response. His account describes a practical change in when the audience sees Freddy act, rather than simply an increase in the amount of violence. The possession story needed an earlier consequence for the threats Jesse was hearing.
The transformations required mechanisms that could make Jesse's body behave impossibly. Effects artist Mark Shostrom described pushing a cast of Freddy's face through a stretchy artificial stomach, then using a dummy of Jesse for the emergence of the rest of Freddy. He linked the image to Freddy's face pressing through a wall in the first film. Kevin Yagher's work included the killer's revised makeup and a mechanical head for his final collapse. Several people operated its movements and supplied blood and ooze. Yagher was unhappy with how briefly the finished film showed the melting effect; Shostrom likewise regretted the reduced visibility of a moving tongue he had made. Their accounts reveal a difference between constructing an elaborate effect and deciding how much of it belongs in a scene. The audience sees the result of both choices.
Mark Patton's relationship with Jesse continued long after he played him. In a later interview, Patton described writing Jesse's Lost Journals, a story that eventually branches away from the film into a different life for the character. His affection for Jesse also informed the documentary Scream, Queen! My Nightmare on Elm Street. Patton discussed his anger at screenwriter David Chaskin's earlier explanations of the film's gay implications and his own wish to address the treatment he had received. He also described a change in his encounters with audiences, from hostile messages to fans who recognised something of themselves in Jesse. These are Patton's accounts of the part and its aftermath. They give the film's reception a personal cost and a personal connection, rather than reducing its queer audience to a single joke about the sequel.
Sholder's later comments leave room for readings beyond the one he remembers bringing to the shoot. He welcomed interpretations that could make a coherent argument from the film and expressed pleasure that LGBTQ+ viewers had found a personal connection with it. That openness matters beside Patton's very different account of what the film and its public reception had meant to him. A director's retrospective explanation cannot settle every participant's intention or experience. Jesse's fear, his attempts to seek help from Grady and Lisa, and the repeated loss of control over his body remain the actions the story gives its audience. The school-bus ending also refuses a simple finish to that struggle. Whatever comfort the factory scene offers, Jesse's final journey to school brings Freddy back into the frame before the credits can close his story.

