Behind the film
- Year
- 1992
- Director
- Penny Marshall
- Writers
- Lowell Ganz, Babaloo Mandel
- Genres
- Female buddy, Comedy drama, Comedy
- Production
- Penny Marshall
- Country
- United States
- Cast
- Geena Davis, Lori Petty, Tom Hanks, Madonna, Rosie O'Donnell, Bill Pullman, Bitty Schram, Jon Lovitz
About the film
Contains story spoilers.
The real All-American Girls Professional Baseball League operated from 1943 to 1954. Penny Marshall's A League of Their Own uses that history for a fictional story about women deciding what place baseball will have in their lives. The Library of Congress describes the film through women's changing wartime roles, choices and solidarity. That approach allows the teammates to want different things from the same opportunity: a job away from home, a chance to compete, or a life that can include both marriage and sport. Dottie joins for Kit's sake; they insist scout Ernie take Marla too. Manager Jimmy Dugan initially dismisses the Peaches, leaving Dottie to lead. Publicity builds the league, but Kit resents Dottie's prominence and moves to Racine.
Geena Davis connected Marshall's authority on set with the women she was directing. In Elisa Leonelli's 1992 interviews, excerpted again by Cultural Daily in 2018, Davis considered a woman director appropriate for a story about an earlier generation of women whose abilities were undervalued. She thought Marshall's own struggle to reach a position of power could bring a feminist perspective to the film. Davis also described her as capable, assured and firmly in control. Tom Hanks put the emphasis elsewhere: he felt her particular personality determined her approach more than her gender. Having already worked with her on Big, he described a collaboration that could frustrate and anger him while still producing the performance she wanted. His account explains how that freedom worked. Marshall chose actors who understood the film in the same way she did, then allowed them room to perform. She used their existing strengths but drew something further out of them during the work. Hanks did not describe a director spelling out every required gesture. He described someone who knew what the story needed and trusted a shared understanding to help the actors reach it.
The cast's teamwork also had to survive assumptions about a mostly female ensemble. Speaking to Lizzy Dening for Vogue in 2022, Davis recalled journalists treating feminism as a risky word and eagerly asking about quarrels between the women. She answered that they supported one another as a team. Her memories of Indiana included sweltering August weather and clouds that kept interrupting filming, alongside friendships that continued afterwards. Playing Dottie also changed her understanding of her body: discovering her coordination at 36 gave her an athletic confidence she had not previously known she possessed.
For Lori Petty, the baseball itself felt familiar. She told Amanda Whiting at Bustle in 2022 that she had grown up playing sports, so spending each day on the field came naturally. Her recollection centres on the concentration of working, playing and sleeping, with little time left for much else. She remembered enjoying the job without knowing how long audiences would keep returning to it. Petty also recalled Marshall assigning her to share a makeup trailer with Madonna. Petty initially wondered why the much more famous performer had not been paired with Davis. Marshall's reasoning, as Petty understood it, was that Petty could be herself around Madonna without becoming intimidated or behaving strangely. The arrangement became an ordinary working relationship. Petty remembered Madonna arriving after an eight-mile run, already having dealt with business in several cities while others were still waking up. Petty described her as pleasant company who wanted to work hard and give a good performance in the film.
The film's team life has a useful comparison in Jeneane Lesko's memories of the Grand Rapids Chicks. Interviewed by Michael Rothman for ABC News in 2017, Lesko recalled trying out, seeing the posted selection list and feeling exposed in a skirted uniform after normally wearing jeans. She played in the league's final two seasons, in the 1950s; these were her experiences after the war, rather than a personal account of the film's 1943 season. She remembered living with host families and players sending earnings home. Lesko identified particular differences from the film. She said pranks on chaperones were playful rather than contemptuous, and rejected the scene in which the manager uses the bathroom in the women's dressing area: coaches would never have done that in her experience. She also recalled families discovering the players' baseball past after Hall of Fame attention and the movie brought it back into public view.
Betty loses her husband in the war. Dottie's wounded husband Bob returns, and she leaves with him before rejoining for the deciding game. Dottie drives in the lead; Kit hits, ignores the stop sign and collides with her at home plate. Dottie drops the ball; Racine wins. The sisters reconcile before Dottie leaves with Bob. In 1988, Dottie reunites with Kit and the surviving players at Cooperstown. Bob has died; she learns Jimmy and Evelyn have died too. They sing Evelyn's team song and pose for a photograph. Baseball continues during the closing credits.

