
The Well-Beloved
Sculptor Jocelyn Pierston believes an ideal beloved moves through the women he encounters.
About
Spoiler notice: Full-plot spoilers for the 1897 book version, including the three Avices, the abandoned wedding and Pierston’s marriage to Marcia.
The Well-Beloved follows a sculptor who repeatedly believes he has found the same ideal woman in a different person. Jocelyn Pierston calls this elusive presence his Well-Beloved, treating changes in his affections as movements of something outside himself. Hardy arranges the story around Pierston at twenty, forty and sixty, allowing the people he encounters to age while his desire keeps searching for a fresh embodiment. Much of the action returns to the rocky Isle of Slingers, the novel’s version of Portland, where stone provides both an industry and the material associated with his art. This account follows the 1897 book version. Hardy had published an earlier version in 1892, but rewrote portions for the later narrative rather than simply reissuing the same story.
Returning from the wider world as a young man, Pierston visits his childhood neighbour Avice Caro. Her spontaneous kiss embarrasses them both when his surprise makes her conscious of the difference between their old familiarity and his newly acquired manners. He wants to repair the hurt, but his affection does not rest securely on the person in front of him. His habit of imagining an ideal beloved makes even kindness part of an unsettled emotional search. Marcia Bencomb soon offers another direction for that search. Their fathers’ rivalry in the stone trade complicates the prospect of a marriage, while Marcia’s independence makes the proposed union less easily arranged than Pierston expects. The first phase establishes a pattern in which his plans outrun his understanding of other people’s wishes.
At forty, Pierston encounters the daughter of the first Avice and becomes attached to the likeness between the generations. Ann Avice Caro appears to offer a return to something he failed to secure in youth, but her resemblance cannot make her history or feelings identical to her mother’s. She has a romantic life of her own, including a marriage to Isaac Pierston that she has concealed. Jocelyn’s proposal brings that existing commitment into the open instead of providing the fresh beginning he imagines. Even the shared surname belongs to the island’s overlapping families, not to an exclusive bond between artist and beloved. His attempt to recognise a persistent ideal has repeatedly left him slow to recognise the actual circumstances of the young woman beside him.
His response to this disappointment is also capable of practical generosity. When the second Avice gives birth, Jocelyn waits outside and helps bring Isaac back into the household, offering the prospect of work to support their reconciliation. The baby is to be called Avice too, extending the family pattern into a third generation. The reunion does not produce an uncomplicated happy marriage: later information tells Jocelyn that Isaac initially mistreated his wife, before absorption in a prospering business brought a more indifferent domestic settlement. Money and useful intervention can change circumstances without creating tenderness. That distinction matters as the novel follows Pierston’s continued life as an artist, because the beauty he pursues in successive women cannot tell him what their daily existence will become.
By sixty, Pierston’s attachment reaches the third Avice, whose mother encourages a marriage that would give her daughter security and social standing. The second Avice can see this as the completion of a family romance, with her daughter obtaining what earlier generations missed. The younger woman’s feelings are less compliant than the proposed arrangement suggests. On the morning of the intended wedding, a letter reveals that she has fled with Henri Leverre after nursing him through the night. They leave to marry; she is not already secretly his wife when the plan collapses. Her mother dies after learning of the flight. The thwarted wedding therefore breaks two different expectations at once, ending Pierston’s latest pursuit and the mother’s hopes for her daughter’s future.
Marcia returns to Pierston’s life through these events: Henri is her stepson, so the young couple’s flight joins their histories in an unexpected way. After the second Avice’s funeral, Pierston becomes dangerously ill. During his recovery, with Marcia helping to care for him, he discovers that his former response to beauty has disappeared. The loss extends beyond romantic attraction to the statues and paintings that once gave his life its purpose. He visits his studio and can no longer feel an attachment to its contents, eventually arranging for the collection to be dispersed. What might look like the destruction of his vocation also brings him relief. The ideal that seemed to promise continuity has imposed a succession of desires and disappointments from which he now feels released.
Pierston and Marcia return to the island and eventually marry on the basis of companionship, with neither pretending to recreate an earlier passion. Their age and physical discomforts give this union ordinary needs: sharing a house and avoiding its neighbour’s smoking chimneys matter alongside the tidier ending their acquaintances want for them. The third Avice and Henri still have difficulties of their own, briefly bringing another marital quarrel into the older couple’s home. Pierston’s attention meanwhile moves towards practical improvements, including water pipes and replacement housing. Even his reputation is detached from his actual condition: young critics begin speaking of him as though he were dead. He remains alive beyond the artistic story they tell, occupied with a different set of concerns from those that once governed his existence.
Book details
- Author
- Thomas Hardy
- First published
- 1897
- Series
- No series listed
- Subgenre
- Literary fiction, Modern classics
- Primary genre
- Literary Fiction
- Tags
- No tags for this book.
Review
Editor profile
Baby Bat
Goodreads and social links will be added soon.
- Goodreads — link coming soon
- Social media — link coming soon
