
The Trumpet-Major
Near the Wessex coast, Anne Garland’s uncertain feelings for the Loveday brothers unfold as the country prepares for invasion by Napoleon.
About
Spoiler notice: Full-plot spoilers, including Anne’s inheritance, her choice between the Loveday brothers and John’s fate.
The Trumpet-Major brings the Napoleonic wars into a village through the lives of people waiting, preparing and falling in love near the Wessex coast. Anne Garland and her widowed mother occupy part of Miller Loveday’s large mill, where the sound of machinery and the flour drifting through their rooms make the household’s work part of their daily surroundings. Their limited means sit beside a concern for gentility, but neighbourly familiarity gradually softens social distinctions. When troops arrive on the nearby down, military spectacle becomes an immediate presence rather than distant newspaper news. Hardy places a complicated courtship inside this changing local world, where a man’s duties can take him away just as his private hopes appear closest to fulfilment.
Anne attracts three very different suitors. Festus Derriman expects the advantages associated with his uncle’s property to support a claim on her attention, but his aggressive pursuit makes him someone she wants to avoid. The Loveday brothers offer contrasting kinds of appeal: John is the reserved soldier and trumpet-major, while Robert, usually called Bob, belongs to the sea and has a more easygoing charm. Anne’s uncertainty is not simply a contest in which the most deserving man must win. Her feelings can change, and kindness towards someone does not necessarily become romantic attachment. The household and its neighbours repeatedly bring these possibilities together, so that family loyalty and courtship cannot be kept apart for long. Each brother has to consider the other’s hopes as well as his own.
John’s conduct towards Bob becomes especially difficult over Matilda Johnson, the woman Bob expects to marry. Recognising a history connected with his regiment, John arranges for her departure and then has to tell his brother that he was responsible. Bob’s first explanations for her absence have blamed the family’s plain surroundings and supposed failures of hospitality. Learning that John intervened produces a different injury: he objects to being protected without being allowed to make his own decision. John, meanwhile, has helped Matilda with her luggage and money, trying to avoid a public scandal rather than exposing her to the household. The episode shows that his care for others can require secret action, but also that a protective intention cannot prevent someone else from experiencing it as betrayal.
The threat of invasion gives these personal disagreements an uneasy background. Proclamations, military preparation and reports of ships draw the villagers into a national emergency, though their responses retain the awkwardness of ordinary local life. Men drilling near the church have to imagine weapons they do not possess, while the demands of practice compete with the preparations for worship. The sea is both the place from which danger may arrive and the place to which Bob’s work and service take him. News therefore has a practical importance for Anne and the Lovedays: a newspaper can connect them with an absent man, but cannot provide the reassurance of his presence. Public courage and domestic anxiety occupy the same landscape, without the latter becoming less immediate because the former is celebrated.
John’s loyalty to Bob also shapes his own chances with Anne. Even when she offers encouragement, he tries to turn her attention towards his brother, speaking of Bob’s naval service instead of accepting the intimacy she invites. Small actions make the restraint visible: an offered walk, a difficult crossing and a cap ribbon that needs tying become opportunities he struggles not to take. Anne can interpret this refusal as indifference, because she does not simply share his understanding of what he owes his brother. He is forced to carry feelings that his outward behaviour keeps contradicting. The courtship’s pain comes partly from that mismatch, with the reader able to recognise a devotion that the person receiving its awkward consequences has reason to question.
A separate story of property and concealment changes Anne’s material position. After Uncle Benjy Derriman dies, his missing deed-box is eventually discovered behind the chimney-board in her bedroom. It contains a will that makes her executrix and leaves her almost all his estate, including Oxwell Hall. Festus receives five small freehold houses, enough to support him without the much larger fortune he might have expected. The discovery gives Anne an independence that no longer has to be obtained through a suitor’s prospects. It does not, however, settle the emotional question between the Lovedays. By the closing stages Bob has returned as a lieutenant, and the brothers’ relationship remains part of the choice Anne must make for herself rather than an arrangement that money can resolve.
The ending brings several apparent settlements together before exposing their unequal costs. Festus marries Matilda, and Anne agrees to marry Bob after six months. As John prepares to leave with his regiment, she acknowledges that she had confused gratitude with love when she encouraged him. He answers with an appearance of cheerful indifference, allowing her to believe in his ability to find another attachment. The farewell seems to preserve everyone’s dignity, but Hardy gives the reader knowledge the departing household does not have: five of the seven soldiers Anne has just wished well, including John, will die within the following years. John’s final movement is into the night and towards a Spanish battlefield. His restraint secures no later reward, and the domestic resolutions remain shadowed by the war continuing beyond them.
Book details
- Author
- Thomas Hardy
- First published
- 1880
- Series
- No series listed
- Subgenre
- Historical fiction, Literary historical fiction, Victorian fiction
- Primary genre
- Historical Fiction, Literary Fiction
- Tags
- No tags for this book.
Review
Editor profile
Baby Bat
Goodreads and social links will be added soon.
- Goodreads — link coming soon
- Social media — link coming soon
