
The Soul of a Bishop
Edward Scrope, Bishop of Princhester, has built his life around the Anglican Church and its inherited beliefs.
About
Spoiler notice: This overview includes Scrope's resignation, his rejection of Lady Sunderbund's religious project and the ending.
Edward Scrope's spiritual crisis first appears as a nightmare. Religious disputants crowd his sleeping mind, a great symbolic eye blazes above them, and a question about the Trinity survives into wakefulness without becoming easier to answer. The Lord Bishop of Princhester has recently been drawn into a dinner-party argument that exposed uncertainty beneath his accustomed dignity. Now the argument repeats itself in a room where even his abandoned clothes remind him of his office. H. G. Wells begins The Soul of a Bishop with this uncomfortable combination of theological language, physical exhaustion and wounded authority. Scrope cannot dismiss what happened as a mere social embarrassment, because the failure to defend his beliefs has made him wonder what he means when he professes them.
His earlier life has offered little preparation for that question. The narrator describes a churchman who accepted the assumptions of his childhood rectory and advanced through a successful career without a fundamental break in belief. With Lady Ella and their five daughters, he has enjoyed the security of a settled domestic world. Princhester introduces conditions that do not fit that world so readily. Its industrial landscape, social antagonisms and resistance to the Church make the work of a bishop less reassuring than the title suggests. Wells examines Scrope's habits of thought through the contrast between inherited confidence and unfamiliar experience. The account can be sharply satirical, especially when the bishop treats the standards of his own upbringing as though they must remain the concealed truth beneath everybody else's life.
Insomnia makes the division between religious and bodily distress increasingly difficult to maintain. Scrope hopes a familiar doctor will offer a reassuring way back to comfort, but Brighton-Pomfrey is away and the younger Dr. Dale receives him instead. Dale's questions and manner irritate the patient, while his explanation suggests that mental habits, physical changes and uncertainty may be interacting. He proposes an experimental tonic whose identity the narrative does not establish. Scrope accepts it with misgivings and then feels an extraordinary assurance of God's presence. The sequence leaves the medical intervention inseparable from the experience that follows. The book explores what Scrope makes of that experience; it does not require the reader to accept his first certainty as independent proof of a supernatural event.
What he takes to be revelation gradually becomes incompatible with continuing his official life unchanged. His search concerns a God who cannot be adequately contained by the doctrinal formulas he has been expected to repeat or by the institutional habits he has helped maintain. Resigning the bishopric gives those doubts material consequences. In plain clothes, he no longer enjoys the same automatic recognition, and his family's move into a cramped London house reveals how much their comfort depended upon the office. His wife has not experienced the conviction that seems decisive to him. Their difficulty is therefore more serious than agreeing on a new address or a smaller income: he must explain a sacrifice whose necessity is clear in his own mind but cannot simply be transferred into hers.
Lady Sunderbund offers another route through the uncertainty. Her wealth and enthusiasm seem capable of giving his religious message a place to be heard, but the proposed temple acquires ornaments, plans and assumptions that trouble him. He sees the danger of reproducing the distinction between priest and followers that he wants to escape. She has invested her feelings as well as her money, and his rejection becomes a personal wound. Their discussion moves between practical changes to the building and her insistence that she has done everything for him. His attraction and remorse complicate his effort to withdraw. The problem cannot be solved by making the temple plainer if the relationship still invites him to become an admired spiritual authority whose followers accept his conclusions on trust.
His daughter Eleanor brings the question of authority into another setting. She has met Riverton, a young officer shortly to leave for the front, and their affection has become urgent under the threat of separation. Scrope initially speaks with the caution of a father accustomed to judging what is safe. Eleanor challenges the idea that her life should be preserved from every risk, and he comes to recognize a responsibility he cannot discharge by deciding everything for her. He lets the pair spend time together without claiming to know what their future will bring. The war makes the stakes visible, but the novel does not supply Riverton's later fate. The encounter helps Scrope reconsider how his own search for certainty relates to the freedom of the people he loves.
Back at home, he explains that he has refused the income attached to the religious project and tries to account for the discomfort his choices have imposed. His family's response is quieter than he expected, and their willingness to follow him becomes a fresh concern: he wants them to encounter belief for themselves. The final reflections return him to prayer, affection, regret and the limits of understanding. He recognizes the possibility that those closest to him may become dependent upon his authority precisely when he hopes to free them from it. His conviction persists, but its clearest moments cannot be maintained continuously or turned into a complete explanation of existence. The story ends with that qualification, leaving him to live within the ordinary limitations that his visions have illuminated without abolishing.
Book details
- Author
- H. G. Wells
- First published
- 1917
- Series
- No series listed
- Subgenre
- Literary fiction, Modern classics
- Primary genre
- Literary Fiction
- Tags
- No tags for this book.
Review
Editor profile
Baby Bat
Goodreads and social links will be added soon.
- Goodreads — link coming soon
- Social media — link coming soon
