V4mp

Explore V4mp

Baby Bat’s library

Find your next route. Get back to playing.

BookLiterary Fiction
← Back to the literary fiction shelf
Vintage paperback cover of The Rachel Incident by Caroline O'Donoghue

The Rachel Incident

Caroline O'Donoghue2023Literary fictionCampus novelComing-of-age

In Cork during the recession, university student Rachel Murray shares a house and a bookshop job with James Devlin, her closest friend.

About

Spoiler notice: Spoilers for the opening setup and Rachel and James’s early arrangement: Rachel develops a crush on her married professor, Dr. Fred Byrne, and James helps her plan a bookstore event that brings the professor into their orbit. Their friendship changes after Byrne’s interest turns toward James. Later secrets, relationship outcomes and the novel’s final events are not summarized.

Rachel Murray looks back on her student life in Cork, where she was a university student working at a bookshop and trying to imagine what an English degree can offer during the recession. She meets James Devlin at work, and the two become close quickly: he invites her to share a house, and their daily life starts to feel like its own small world. The book’s title points toward the event that later binds them to Dr. Fred Byrne, Rachel’s married Victorian-literature professor. The arrangement they devise for him is meant to help Rachel get closer to her crush, but the evening redirects the relationship among all three.

The novel opens years later, with Rachel living in London, pregnant and working as a journalist for a newspaper serving Irish people abroad. A television assignment brings her back into contact with the Cork past she has not often discussed, and the narrative moves from that present into her early twenties. Rachel tells the story retrospectively, with the distance to recognize how young she was and how much she did not understand at the time. The frame gives the past a second life: what once seemed like one awkward incident looks different when Rachel has had years to live with its consequences.

James is Rachel’s closest friend and housemate, as well as her coworker at the bookshop. He presents himself as straight when they meet, while Rachel assumes she understands him; their early friendship includes the small misreadings and repairs that come with wanting someone’s company before knowing how to be careful with them. Their closeness is central to the book’s emotional movement. When Rachel confides her attraction to Byrne, James supports her plan for a bookstore event around the professor’s academic work. The plan does not produce the seduction Rachel expects. Byrne’s desire is directed toward James, and Rachel becomes part of the secret that follows.

Fred Byrne is a lecturer whose classroom is devoted to Victorian literature, while the students’ and shop workers’ lives outside it are shaped by precarious work, money worries and uncertain plans. He is married to Deenie, a well-connected woman who works in publishing and later employs Rachel. Deenie’s home and social circle offer Rachel and James a glimpse of a more settled, cultivated adult life, complete with its own habits and blind spots. Because the younger pair become entangled with both members of the marriage, the book keeps shifting the line between mentor, employer, friend and romantic partner. Their ages and positions give each encounter a different balance of power.

Rachel’s boyfriend Carey brings another kind of uncertainty into this already crowded circle. He is also called James, so Rachel uses his surname to distinguish him from the friend she already lives with. They meet on a night out when she asks him for a cigarette, and their attraction becomes a relationship whose everyday arrangements are less dependable than their feelings. Carey struggles to arrive at work on time or keep his phone charged; Rachel tries to interpret that disorder as distance or a refusal to commit. Those ordinary failures matter to someone who is already trying to guess what the people around her mean. Their intimacy develops alongside her friendship with James and the secrets surrounding the Byrnes.

The Cork chapters place the characters in the shadow of Ireland’s financial crash. Rachel and James share a poorly heated home and try to maintain a bohemian life even as jobs and money are hard to come by. Their ambitions stretch toward London and more secure work, but the future does not arrive on schedule. The setting is specific in its Irish references and in the social conditions of the period, including the restrictions around reproductive healthcare. Those pressures enter the characters’ private lives rather than sitting apart as background history: economic uncertainty affects where they can go, while the laws and public attitudes of the time shape what choices feel possible.

The book’s first-person voice stays close to Rachel, but the events it recounts are driven by a group of people with competing accounts of what they owe one another. James can be both the person Rachel trusts most and the person whose secrecy changes her sense of their friendship. Byrne’s marriage and his position at the university complicate the story of who can be candid with whom. Deenie’s work relationship with Rachel adds another layer: a younger woman trying to belong in a household whose rules she only partly understands. Later Rachel has to consider what she herself concealed, and how protection can look different to each person involved.

The long friendship between Rachel and James gives the title incident its lasting weight. A crush and a bookstore event may be the doorway into the plot, but the story keeps returning to the life the two friends build together and the ways they fail to tell each other the truth. The friends share a home and ambitions, but their loyalty also draws them into decisions that affect people outside that home. Rachel’s later narration holds affection for the person she was without pretending that affection makes every old choice harmless. The novel follows her attempt to understand that early chapter while remaining connected to the people who lived through it with her.

Book details

Author
Caroline O'Donoghue
First published
2023
Series
No series listed
Subgenre
Literary fiction, Campus novel, Coming-of-age
Primary genre
Literary Fiction, Romance
Tags
No tags for this book.

Review

Review coming soon

Editor profile

Books editor

Baby Bat

Goodreads and social links will be added soon.

  • Goodreads — link coming soon
  • Social media — link coming soon