
The Mercies
On Christmas Eve 1617, a storm kills forty fishermen on the Norwegian island of Vardø, including Maren Magnusdatter’s father and brother.
About
Spoiler notice: Spoilers for the premise and early setup: a 1617 storm kills forty fishermen in Vardø. Later, Absalom Cornet arrives with his wife Ursa as commissioner, and Maren and Ursa are drawn together while suspicion of the women’s independence grows. Later revelations and the ending are not summarized.
On Christmas Eve in 1617, a storm strikes the Norwegian island of Vardø while Maren Magnusdatter watches from the shore. Forty fishermen, including her father and brother, are lost. The disaster leaves the settlement without most of its men and forces the women to take on the work and decisions that sustain the community. Hargrave begins with a natural catastrophe, but its consequences are social as well as personal: grief sits alongside practical necessity, and the old arrangements of authority no longer fit the people who remain. The island’s exposed position in the far north gives this change a physical setting. Sea, weather and distance shape what the women can do, while their isolation makes the community itself the place where survival, belief and power will be contested.
The novel then moves forward to the arrival of Absalom Cornet, a Scottish man sent to take authority in Vardø. He comes with his Norwegian wife, Ursa, whose life beside him is marked by both deference to his position and fear of it. The women of Vardø are unlike the world Ursa has known: they work, make decisions and manage their lives with a degree of independence. She is drawn to Maren and to the island community, while Absalom interprets their way of life through a religious framework that makes it appear dangerous. Their different readings of the same place give the book its central pressure. What looks to one person like competence born of necessity can look to another like disobedience or evidence of evil.
The opening makes that changed life concrete through the work already under way before the storm. Maren sits with her mother and her pregnant sister-in-law Diinna, stitching wind-torn fishing sailcloth. Her brother Erik has brought white heather from the mainland to dry for bedding, while the family watches the boats leave for the fishing grounds. These are not decorative details: fish are Vardø’s food, trade and livelihood, and weather governs whether the boats can return. The novel’s domestic spaces are crowded too. Erik and Diinna share a narrow room against Maren’s, and the future home Maren expects to make with Dag is still being built from a boathouse. The loss therefore breaks into a life of shared rooms, seasonal labour and plans not yet completed.
The storm also alters family relationships in specific ways. Alongside her father and Erik, Maren loses the future she had begun to imagine with Dag, her intended husband. Diinna is left pregnant and connected to Maren through both kinship and the Sámi customs she brings into their household. Before Erik leaves, she presses her thumb to his forehead in a gesture meant to guide him home from the sea. Her place in the family brings the island's prejudice against Sámi people into Maren's home. The women share a bereavement, but they do not share the same standing in the settlement. Their kinship has to endure tensions that were present before the boats went out.
Maren and Ursa provide two distinct ways into the story. Maren is rooted in Vardø and its losses; Ursa comes from Bergen and is married to the new commissioner sent to oversee the community. Their perspectives move the narrative between a woman living through the aftermath of the storm and a newcomer tied to the authority imposing a new order. Ursa's position is not secure simply because she is the commissioner's wife. She is subject to her husband's power, yet she can see that the women's competence is not the evil he claims. Her bond with Maren develops across that divide, bringing affection into a marriage and a settlement where obedience is expected.
The historical setting includes the 1621 witch trials, but the danger begins with familiar practices being treated as suspicious. Rune stones kept for safety and fox skins offered for protection help the women cope with their losses. These customs meet a religious order hostile to older beliefs, especially those associated with Sámi people. Absalom brings experience of witch-burning from Scotland, and his authority makes his interpretation of the island consequential. A household ritual can become an accusation in someone else's mouth. The women's efforts to protect themselves after one catastrophe leave them exposed to another kind of threat, one carried by officials who insist that their own account of evil is the only permissible explanation.
The Mercies takes its starting point from the real storm and the persecution that followed, then imagines the lives of women caught between them. Maren and Ursa's relationship belongs to that fictional reconstruction; it should not be mistaken for a surviving account of two historical witnesses. The distinction matters in a story about whose account is allowed to survive. Official suspicion imposes categories of guilt on women whose everyday concerns have already been established through their work and family relationships. Its attention stays close to the women who must live with that danger, including the awkward, intimate business of continuing to share a home.
Book details
- Author
- Kiran Millwood Hargrave
- First published
- 2020
- Series
- No series listed
- Subgenre
- Literary historical fiction, Historical fiction
- Primary genre
- Historical Fiction, Literary Fiction
- Tags
- No tags for this book.
Review
Editor profile
Baby Bat
Goodreads and social links will be added soon.
- Goodreads — link coming soon
- Social media — link coming soon
