V4mp

Explore V4mp

Baby Bat’s library

Find your next route. Get back to playing.

BookFantasy
← Back to the fantasy shelf
Cover of Piranesi by Susanna Clarke

Piranesi

Susanna Clarke2020Portal fantasy

Piranesi lives in the House, an endless building of halls and statues with tides that sweep through the lower levels, and he keeps a careful journal of the rooms, the birds and the bones.

About

Spoiler notice: Contains moderate spoilers for the novel's central mystery, including the discovery that Piranesi's understanding of his past and the Other's account of events cannot both be trusted. It does not describe the final resolution.

Susanna Clarke's Piranesi is a standalone novel told through the notebooks of a man who calls himself Piranesi. The House he inhabits appears to contain a seemingly endless system of halls, vestibules and staircases, with thousands of statues set throughout it. An ocean occupies the lower halls; its tides climb the stairs and can flood rooms, while clouds drift through the upper levels. Piranesi records these changes as practical knowledge. He knows which passages flood and when, where to find food, and how to move safely through a place whose scale defeats any ordinary map.

The journals introduce a small cast by Piranesi's own count. He considers the skeletons he finds in different parts of the House to be its Dead, and he visits them, gives them names and brings offerings. The only other living person he believes he sees regularly is a man he calls the Other, who arrives twice a week. The Other is searching for what he calls a Great and Secret Knowledge and asks Piranesi to help with research. Their meetings give the narrator a schedule and a companion, but their relationship is unequal: the Other directs the inquiry and dismisses questions that Piranesi raises about the House or its history.

Piranesi's manner of life is not presented at first as a crisis. He describes the House with gratitude and close attention, treating its tides, statues and weather as features of a world worth studying. His observations make the setting legible in small, local ways even as its total layout stays beyond him. The dated entries also show how much he depends on routine: he tends to his shelter, gathers what the House provides, maps rooms, and maintains a record of what he has learned. This calm method gives the book a concrete daily rhythm before the story makes that rhythm uncertain.

That change begins when the Other says there may be someone new in the House, a person he calls Sixteen, and warns Piranesi against them. Soon there are signs that do not fit the account Piranesi has been given: messages appear in chalk, and details in the journals invite comparison with what he remembers. He does not solve the problem through a sudden revelation. Instead, he checks notes, revisits places and tests one statement against another. The mystery grows out of the same habits that previously helped him survive, as keeping records becomes a way to examine the reliability of both his own memory and the Other's explanations.

As he follows these clues, Piranesi encounters evidence that the House has a history beyond the one he knows and that the Other's research may be bound up with his own circumstances. The novel gradually adds information about the person represented by Sixteen and about events outside the House, shifting the question from what the place contains to how Piranesi came to live there and what has happened to his past. The unfolding account includes missing writings that must be recovered and read alongside the notebooks already in hand. Those fragments alter the meaning of earlier entries without making Piranesi's present observations worthless. A police visit and attempted rescue then force the question of how the House relates to the world beyond it into the present, rather than leaving it as a theory reconstructed from journals. Piranesi's attachment to the House complicates that intervention: the place has been his home, and he feels responsible for its Dead.

The House's regions demand different forms of movement and attention. Some journeys into the Drowned Halls, where fish can be found, require Piranesi to climb into the Upper Halls and descend through breaks in the floors; the staircases are built on a scale that makes each step difficult for a human-sized traveler. Clouds can obscure a room, while the statues there may depict violent scenes unlike the calm or joyful figures he describes elsewhere. In one recorded event, three tides converge, and his calculation of their volume proves wrong. He is nearly swept from the wall before the water recedes. The House's beauty is inseparable from an environment that requires practical judgment and can exceed it.

The Other's visits also bring objects Piranesi has never found for himself: notebooks, shoes and devices that shine. Rather than treating this difference as proof that the Other knows more about the world beyond the House, Piranesi explains the supplies through his own belief that the House provides for its inhabitants. He supposes the gifts compensate for skills the Other lacks, and remains concerned for his companion's welfare. This detail makes their disagreement about the House more than a clash of personalities. Piranesi reads generosity and belonging into the same place where the Other searches for a Great and Secret Knowledge, while the reader can see that their accounts of ordinary things do not match.

Book details

Author
Susanna Clarke
First published
2020
Series
No series listed
Subgenre
Portal fantasy
Primary genre
Fantasy
Tags
No tags for this book.

Review

Review coming soon

Editor profile

Books editor

Baby Bat

Goodreads and social links will be added soon.

  • Goodreads — link coming soon
  • Social media — link coming soon