
Joan and Peter
Peter and Joan grow up among adults with competing ideas about religion, schooling and the life a child should be prepared to lead.
About
Spoiler notice: This overview discusses the parents’ deaths, Joan and Peter’s marriage, Peter’s wartime injuries and the final chapter.
Joan and Peter begins with a birth in 1893, when the apparent permanence of Queen Victoria’s reign forms part of the security surrounding a new child. Peter’s parents are modern in their own estimation: they have ideas about health, upbringing and how a family should live. Yet their ideas have histories of their own. Arthur Stubland’s artistic ambitions and Dolly’s appetite for books, science and a more consequential life do not give them a simple understanding of each other. Wells follows these adults before the children can speak for themselves, showing how a younger generation inherits the results of older people’s enthusiasms and mistakes. The subtitle, The Story of an Education, consequently extends beyond classrooms. Education begins in the expectations, relationships and decisions that prepare a child’s world before he enters it.
The responsibility for that world changes abruptly when Arthur and Dolly drown during a visit to Italy. Their wills do not even agree about how guardianship should work: Dolly names Oswald Sydenham alone, while Arthur includes him among four guardians. Joan, their adopted daughter, is included alongside Peter. Oswald’s response to Dolly’s death brings his own disappointment and jealousy into the story before grief forces a clearer recognition of what has been lost. His later commitment to the children is therefore personal as well as practical. A wounded veteran with experience in Africa, he has convictions about public service and human improvement, but conviction does not exempt him from possessiveness or error. The guardian who wants to equip two young people for life must also confront what he has failed to understand in his own.
Schooling becomes a prolonged search among arrangements that satisfy different adults for different reasons. Lady Charlotte Sydenham regards religion as an urgent concern and does not consider her authority over the children surrendered merely because Oswald remains away in Uganda. Other relatives and institutions bring their own assumptions about acceptable behaviour and educational success. The narrative moves through preparatory education, later schools and the prospect of Cambridge, with Peter and Joan following distinct routes. Oswald eventually makes a permanent home at Pelham Ford, choosing its position partly in relation to their educational needs. That domestic geography gives his project substance: journeys, schools and a house must be arranged. The larger question is whether an apparently suitable arrangement can produce understanding, rather than simply carry its pupils through an approved sequence.
By the time Joan is nineteen and a half and Peter nearly of age, the project has acquired difficulties no prospectus could solve. A violent quarrel sends them away from the house, leaving Oswald to reconsider the years during which they have become adults. Joan’s complaint about Peter’s treatment of her friends and his relationships makes the disagreement more specific than a general rebellion against authority. Intellectual opportunities have not guaranteed emotional judgment or generosity. Looking back at the children he thought he knew, Oswald is startled by how completely their adult selves have appeared. The novel’s long retrospective movement allows family history and educational argument to meet here. He can review what he selected for them, but he cannot simply select the people they will become or the feelings they will have for one another.
The outbreak of war in 1914 gives those uncertainties a different scale. Questions about preparation for life now have to include a catastrophe that the comfortable routines of education have done little to prevent. Peter enters the Royal Flying Corps, and his eventual work in an observation balloon supplies a concrete picture of how knowledge is used at the front. Maps, instruments and a telephone connection make him part of a larger military system, observing movements and helping direct fire across the landscape below. The wide view can invite speculation, but his position remains exposed and practical. He and Joan marry during the war, with brief intervals together interrupted by service. Their relationship takes shape amid immediate danger and an intensified desire to remain alive, rather than in the orderly future their guardian once tried to arrange.
In the final chapter Peter is convalescent, wounded and no longer fit for active service. Oswald is also physically diminished, living with wartime restrictions, shortages and anxiety. Their discussion of the future refuses to treat the absence of fighting as a sufficient purpose for society. Peter wants intelligence and invention directed towards work that can endure, while Oswald returns to education and international cooperation. These are urgent character arguments, including prejudices and sweeping political judgments, rather than predictions the reader must accept as established truth. Joan brings the discussion down to an occupation she can imagine undertaking. She proposes to learn plumbing, carpentry and bricklaying and then build sensible homes. Her dissatisfaction with inconvenient rooms and wasteful design turns a general ideal of reconstruction into plans for useful spaces people could actually inhabit.
The young couple’s departure leaves Oswald facing the end of his guardianship without the consoling certainty that every problem has been solved. Their education continues beyond school and university, into work, marriage and whatever disappointments they have yet to encounter. Alone, he revisits his own ambitions, injuries, service and losses, wondering what has allowed him to persist. His memories do not become a triumphant account of achievement. He is conscious of limited strength and of purposes he may never see fulfilled, including the international order he hopes will follow the war. The final action is modest: he rises, lights his lamp and returns to the work on his desk. Wells ends this extensive family and educational history with someone continuing to act despite uncertainty, while the younger generation moves beyond the life he could supervise.
Book details
- Author
- H. G. Wells
- First published
- 1918
- Series
- No series listed
- Subgenre
- Literary fiction, Coming-of-age, Family novel
- Primary genre
- Literary Fiction
- Tags
- No tags for this book.
Review
Editor profile
Baby Bat
Goodreads and social links will be added soon.
- Goodreads — link coming soon
- Social media — link coming soon
