
Elmer Gantry
A commanding voice and a hunger for admiration carry Elmer Gantry from college football into preaching, travelling revivals and a prominent pulpit.
About
Spoiler notice: This overview discusses Sharon’s death and the scandal resolved in the final chapter.
Elmer Gantry enters his novel drunk, affectionate, loud and ready to fight an enemy who has not yet appeared. His roommate Jim Lefferts tries to manage him while the bartender enjoys the performance. The scene establishes something that follows Elmer into every pulpit: he has a remarkable voice and an appetite for being heard. At Terwillinger College he has been a successful football captain, but scholarly effort bores him. Public speaking appeals because he can feel an audience respond to his delivery. Sinclair Lewis’s 1927 novel follows the uses he finds for that gift, particularly when religious authority gives his forceful personality a wider stage. Elmer can sound profound before he has worked out what he means, and he often mistakes the pleasure of commanding attention for proof that he deserves it.
His progress toward a religious calling begins among people already eager to claim him as a convert. Fellow students pray over him, instructors become friendly and the college president takes an encouraging interest. Their expectations make salvation a social event as well as a spiritual question. When Elmer has to prepare an address, however, eloquence is harder to manufacture alone at his desk. Jim offers a collection of Robert Ingersoll’s writings, and Elmer borrows from the very freethinker whose irreligion he condemns. What matters in the resulting speech is how successfully the language sounds in his mouth. Lewis takes the reader behind the finished performance, where irritation, calculation and a desire to impress coexist with the emotions Elmer presents to others. His public certainty repeatedly depends on work someone else has done.
With the evangelist Sharon Falconer, Elmer becomes part of a travelling organization whose methods can be discussed almost like sales techniques. They compare hymns, ways to move people toward the altar, approaches to collecting money and even how to count converts. Their conversation with another evangelist exposes disagreements about technique while leaving the competition for audiences intact. Sharon also introduces healing into her meetings. A woman announces that her hearing has returned, but Elmer finds that she cannot hear his questions; he nevertheless sees the publicity value. The display of discarded crutches includes some he buys himself. Sharon’s response is less consistent: she can calculate receipts and also become excited by the possibility that she possesses a genuine gift. Elmer’s relationship with her mixes admiration and dependence with his wish eventually to lead the enterprise himself.
Sharon’s ambitions take physical form in the Waters of Jordan Tabernacle, a converted wooden pier at Clontar. Its opening brings thousands of people, an enormous choir and the promise of a larger religious career. Outside, a workman’s discarded cigarette ignites oily rags, and the flames reach the crowded building. Sharon refuses Elmer’s attempts to lead her away, insisting on faith as the danger spreads. He escapes through a rear door after forcing his way into the crush, then presents himself to reporters as a rescuer. The difference between survival and the account he gives of it is brutal. Sharon dies with the cross in her hand. Afterwards he is genuinely lonely for her and cannot make independent evangelism succeed, so the disaster leaves both an emotional absence and a professional problem he needs to solve.
Work with Mrs. Evans Riddle’s Thought-power organization offers another audience and a new vocabulary of prosperity and self-improvement. Elmer can learn its phrases as he learned those of evangelism. Later, as a powerful minister in Zenith, he helps decide whose beliefs deserve public respect. Frank Shallard provides an uncomfortable comparison. Frank is willing to admit doubts about doctrines while still seeking a church capable of helping people and sustaining a shared life. Elmer attacks that uncertainty as dangerous unbelief and intervenes with Frank’s supporters. The campaign is entangled with rivalry for wealthy church members: a donor alienated from Frank’s congregation would be welcome in Elmer’s. Lewis makes this competition visible through meetings, invitations and private conversations, showing how a dispute presented as a defence of faith can also move influence and money between institutions.
The late scandal threatens Elmer with the kind of public judgment he has helped direct at other people. Oscar Dowler claims that Elmer has taken advantage of his wife Hettie, who has worked as Elmer’s secretary. Once the accusation spreads nationally, important opportunities are put on hold. Elmer’s ally T. J. Rigg resolves the immediate danger through investigation and threats rather than a public examination of Elmer’s conduct. Confronted with details of her past, Hettie signs a statement retracting the allegations. Rigg’s prepared account says that liquor interests paid her to attack an opponent of drinking and that Elmer’s prayer inspired her repentance. The reader has watched this account being manufactured in the room. Its appearance in the newspapers as a vindication therefore reveals how completely the public story can depart from the transaction that produced it.
Elmer still fears facing his congregation. He briefly promises himself that he will become the person he wants everyone else to be, but the reception is overwhelming: people rise, cheer, kneel and pray with him. Offers that had been suspended return with congratulations. His restored authority depends on an audience that wants reassurance and accepts the explanation supplied to it. During his prayer of renewed purity, he notices an attractive new singer and immediately anticipates getting to know her. Nothing interrupts his declaration that a greater moral crusade is beginning. The ending brings the opening’s appetite for attention into an imposing institutional setting, with more people ready to mistake its sound for its substance. Elmer has survived the exposure without acquiring the self-knowledge that might make his promises mean something different next time.
Book details
- Author
- Sinclair Lewis
- First published
- 1927
- Series
- No series listed
- Subgenre
- Literary fiction, Modern classics
- Primary genre
- Literary Fiction
- Tags
- No tags for this book.
Review
Editor profile
Baby Bat
Goodreads and social links will be added soon.
- Goodreads — link coming soon
- Social media — link coming soon
