
Confidence
Asked to help a friend judge a potential wife, Bernard Longueville turns observation into a complicated personal undertaking.
About
Spoiler notice: Full-plot spoilers, including Gordon’s marriage, Bernard’s changed judgement and the final reconciliation.
Bernard Longueville is travelling through Italy with a sketchbook and a considerable talent for enjoying his own thoughts. In Siena he lingers over streets, architecture and the possibilities of making a picture, until an encounter with Angela Vivian gives him somebody else to think about. She challenges his freedom to turn her into a subject without permission. Henry James’s Confidence begins with an observer whose cleverness does not guarantee that he understands the people he observes. Bernard can supply an amusing interpretation very quickly, and his confidence in doing so becomes consequential when a friend asks for help with marriage. A passing meeting in Italy is about to become part of a more elaborate exercise in deciding what a woman is really like.
The request comes from Gordon Wright, who writes to Bernard from Baden-Baden. Gordon describes his interest in marriage with the language of experiments and assistants, inviting his friend to see what impression the woman he is considering will make on him. When Bernard arrives, the company includes Angela, her mother, Blanche Evers and Captain Lovelock. Gordon insists that he wants to marry with his eyes open: being in love might distort the very judgement on which he hopes to rely. Bernard teases him about the contradiction. He nevertheless becomes involved in the requested observation, approaching Angela as someone whose motives need to be discovered. His earlier acquaintance with her gives the task a personal history that Gordon does not initially share.
The resort’s friendships and flirtations give Bernard plenty of material and no reliable protection against misunderstanding it. Angela and her mother are concerned about Blanche’s interest in Captain Lovelock, whom they consider a doubtful marriage prospect because of his gambling, expensive habits and lack of money. Bernard listens to explanations of other people’s feelings while trying to identify Angela’s own intentions. Her manner towards him does not fit comfortably with his understanding of Gordon’s hopes. He eventually gives his friend an unfavourable opinion, believing that she is encouraging attention from more than one direction. The judgement seems to him compatible with loyalty to Gordon. What he has not properly allowed for is Angela’s understanding that the two men have made her the object of a private investigation.
Gordon marries Blanche, and Bernard’s travels take him away from the earlier company. When he meets Angela again in Paris, the renewed acquaintance forces him to reconsider his confident assessment. He admits what he told Gordon: that she was a coquette and a dangerous woman to marry. Angela explains how much she resented being examined on somebody else’s behalf. Once she understood what was happening, she wanted to frustrate the observer rather than make his task easy. That account gives Bernard a different explanation of behaviour he had treated as evidence against her. Their conversation is also a courtship, making the revision personally welcome without making his earlier mistake less serious. The woman he advised against marrying becomes the woman he wants himself.
Bernard and Angela become engaged, leaving him with the difficulty of telling Gordon what his revised opinion means in practice. His friend’s response brings the old advice back into the present. Gordon feels wronged, and his dissatisfaction with his own marriage makes the news harder to receive. He later tells Angela that he expects Blanche to leave with Captain Lovelock, imagining that a divorce could give him another opportunity. This is his expectation, not an accomplished separation. Angela responds without turning the conversation into the final decision Gordon imagines. The pressure falls on Bernard’s friendship as well as his engagement: the men who once treated observation as a useful aid to marriage now have to confront the consequences of the conclusions they drew.
Angela’s intervention depends on looking again at Blanche. She thinks Blanche loves Gordon, despite the complaints and behaviour he has been interpreting otherwise, and urges him to give his wife the admiration she wants from him. Captain Lovelock’s attentions need not mean an intended elopement. Bernard spends an unhappy interval in London, receiving news rather than directing what happens in Paris. He happens to see Lovelock at a theatre, looking no more entertained by the performance than he is himself. A brief letter from Gordon finally calls him back. The summons does not explain whether it signals peace or another quarrel, but Bernard returns immediately, tired of separation and ready to discover whether Angela’s confidence has been better founded than his own earlier judgement.
Gordon comes to Bernard’s rooms and offers his hand. He acknowledges that a husband should value and believe in his wife, and the friendship resumes without requiring him to find Angela entirely simple or easy to understand. Blanche, for her part, remains talkative and capable of supplying her own account of everybody’s conduct. She praises Mrs Vivian’s influence while teasing Bernard about his unexplained journey. The ending then separates the couples geographically. Gordon and Blanche arrange to travel to Cairo for a voyage up the Nile, leaving before Bernard and Angela’s wedding. They send a necklace of pearls as a bridal gift. A long letter from Gordon reaches Bernard during his honeymoon, confirming a marriage and a restored correspondence rather than the permanent rupture both once seemed to face.
Book details
- Author
- Henry James
- First published
- 1879
- Series
- No series listed
- Subgenre
- Literary fiction, Modern classics
- Primary genre
- Literary Fiction
- Tags
- No tags for this book.
Review
Editor profile
Baby Bat
Goodreads and social links will be added soon.
- Goodreads — link coming soon
- Social media — link coming soon
