
Christopher and Columbus
Seventeen-year-old twins Anna-Rose and Anna-Felicitas, orphaned daughters of an English mother and German father, leave Liverpool for America during wartime and adopt the names Christopher and Columbus for their voyage into an unknown future.
About
Spoiler notice: This overview discusses the twins’ American venture, their romantic attachments and the proposals at the ending.
Anna-Rose and Anna-Felicitas give themselves the names Christopher and Columbus while leaving Liverpool aboard the St. Luke. They are seventeen-year-old twins, orphaned and uncertain what will happen if they survive the Atlantic crossing. Calling the journey a discovery of a New World helps them present themselves as adventurers rather than abandoned girls. Their English mother and German father have left them with connections that wartime suspicion turns into liabilities: they belong to both countries without being comfortably accepted in either. Christopher and Columbus begins with the sisters sitting close beneath a rug, determined to look cheerful. The comic confidence of their conversation is inseparable from the practical fact that they have no parents and very little control over where they will next be allowed to stay.
Their recent history explains why America has become the destination. Aunt Alice has tried to arrange a place for them without defying her husband Arthur, whose hostility to their German identity makes continued residence difficult. Work as probationers at a children's hospital offers a temporary solution until prejudice defeats it. The nurses refuse to work with them, and even the children respond to the discovery of who is bringing their food. Von Arnim presents these reactions through the absurdities of respectable behaviour as well as their consequences for the twins. Adults who can describe themselves as charitable still find ways to make two dependent girls unwelcome. The sisters' determination to laugh and improvise develops in circumstances where being dutiful has not secured them a home.
The crossing introduces Mr. Twist, whose willingness to help becomes increasingly important as the girls try to find a place in the United States. Their arrival does not simply complete an escape: arrangements remain uncertain, and they need someone able to negotiate situations they do not fully understand. Mr. Twist supplies practical assistance while discovering an attachment he had not expected. The twins bring their own resourcefulness, curiosity and startling interpretations to that relationship. They can unsettle an adult who is trying to organise their future without recognising all the assumptions on which his plans depend. His protectiveness and their reliance on each other become the centre of a travelling household before any settled household actually exists.
California eventually offers the setting for a more deliberate attempt to belong. The Open Arms is conceived as an inn and tea-room for passing motorists, giving the party somewhere to work as well as somewhere to live. Mr. Twist supplies money and business organisation, but the girls also help turn the idea into a place with an identity. Establishing it requires rooms, furnishings, workers and decisions about who will share daily life there. The undertaking gives their American journey a purpose beyond finding another person willing to receive them. It also puts the problem of hospitality into their own hands. They have experienced how uncomfortable dependence can be, and now their future involves making a business out of welcoming other people.
The preparations have a comic physical energy. Temporary accommodation must be made habitable while the main building is still being worked on, and an outbuilding offers cramped sleeping arrangements rather than effortless comfort. Curtains, cushions and flowers help disguise its shortcomings. The architect and other young tradesmen abandon their usual supervision to assist, while Mr. Twist gathers furniture and cooking utensils. Mrs. Bilton and Li Koo become part of the working household, adding personalities and demands that the original plan cannot entirely contain. These details keep The Open Arms from existing only as a hopeful name. It has to be assembled by people whose ideas about comfort, usefulness and one another do not always agree, and the twins participate in that process with infectious confidence.
The sisters' closeness remains the strongest continuity across all these changes. It is also something romantic attachment can threaten even when the attachment is welcome. Anna-Felicitas falls in love with Commander Elliott of the British Navy, and Anna-Rose sees implications her happy twin has not yet considered. She believes marriage will make Anna-Felicitas English and permit her to return to England, while she herself will remain an enemy alien unable to follow. The fear turns a prospective celebration into the loss of the companion on whom her life has depended. Nationality has already separated the twins from places and opportunities; now it seems capable of separating them from each other. Her distress is therefore bound to the same wartime exclusions that sent them travelling.
Mr. Twist finds Anna-Rose in tears and offers marriage, explaining that he loves her and imagining a future in which they can all travel together. His account of the nationality consequences belongs to his proposal within the story, rather than serving as guidance about citizenship law. He is prepared to accept a marriage in which he supplies the love, but she tells him that she already loves him. The exchange gives both a happiness that neither expected to receive in that form. The final action is a small comic interruption of business: Mr. Twist puts a strip of paper across The Open Arms sign to announce that it is shut. Neither wedding is narrated. The book leaves them at new commitments, with the longer future still ahead of them.
Book details
- Author
- Elizabeth von Arnim
- First published
- 1919
- Series
- No series listed
- Subgenre
- Literary fiction, Historical fiction
- Primary genre
- Literary Fiction, Historical Fiction
- Tags
- No tags for this book.
Review
Editor profile
Baby Bat
Goodreads and social links will be added soon.
- Goodreads — link coming soon
- Social media — link coming soon
