V4mp

Explore V4mp

Baby Bat’s library

Find your next route. Get back to playing.

BookRomance
← Back to the romance shelf
Cover of Caraval by Stephanie Garber

Caraval

Stephanie Garber2017Fantasy romanceFairytale retellingRomantasy (tag)

Scarlett Dragna has spent her life on a small island under her father's control, saving up every story she has heard about Caraval, the once-a-year performance where the audience takes part.

About

Spoiler notice: Major spoilers for the complete first Caraval novel, including the final revelations and epilogue.

Scarlett Dragna has spent years writing to Master Legend, the elusive leader of Caraval, asking him to bring his traveling performance to Trisda. Her letters have gone unanswered, and she is preparing to marry a count she has never met because her father, Governor Dragna, says the match will secure her future. When a reply finally arrives with three tickets, the invitation opens a door Scarlett has wanted to enter for most of her life. It also arrives at the worst possible moment: her father uses Tella’s latest act of defiance to threaten both sisters, and Scarlett believes obedience is the only way to keep Tella safe.

Tella refuses to wait for Scarlett’s wedding to solve their problems. She and Julian, a sailor who has recently appeared in their lives, arrange to get away from Trisda. They take Scarlett away while she is unconscious; she wakes on a raft beside Julian and initially accuses him of kidnapping her. Only afterward does she agree to continue toward Caraval. The journey to Isla de los Sueños makes her choose between the familiar danger of home and the uncertain one of Caraval. A leaking raft and Scarlett’s heavy gown turn that choice physical: she has to let go of the clothes that weigh her down and swim for shore. When she and Julian reach the island, Tella is missing, but clues point toward the game.

Caraval unfolds inside a theatrical island world where time, architecture and ordinary objects behave according to unfamiliar rules. Shops offer impossible wares, doors and rooms change, and the game’s clues send participants across a miniature city of canals, towers, taverns and hidden passages. Before entering, Scarlett hears the repeated assurance that what happens is only a performance; the written rules also warn that participants can be hurt when they mistake play for reality. Those instructions never settle the question for her. She sees apparent danger and loss, while the performers and players keep shifting roles, withholding information and turning her assumptions into part of the spectacle.

Scarlett enters with Julian, pretending they are engaged so they can pass the gate. The first clue leads them to the Glass Serpent, where a marked key and Tella’s name suggest her sister is close. Scarlett finds Tella’s room, but Tella warns her not to come inside. Scarlett respects the warning and loses the chance to speak with her that night. Elsewhere, Dante, a striking performer, offers Scarlett shelter. As the five-night game advances, she follows scraps of information through rooms that respond to fear, a shop of glass eyes, and tunnels beneath the island. Her search for Tella becomes tangled with a second puzzle: whether Julian or Dante is the boy with the black heart named in a clue.

The performance draws Scarlett toward the secrets of her own life as well as Tella’s. Her father arrives on the island, and the man Scarlett is meant to marry turns out to be Count Nicolas d’Arcy, whose courteous letters have hidden an aggressive, entitled stranger. Scarlett’s choice to resist him becomes part of the escape she once thought marriage would provide. She also learns more about Julian’s connection to the game. He and Dante had been investigating Rosa’s death, which they believed was connected to Legend and Caraval. Scarlett is pulled between evidence, affection and fear: each new explanation appears to clarify the game, then another scene makes it uncertain again.

Scarlett reaches the figure presented as Master Legend after following a clue that sends her leaping into a dark passage beneath a carousel. He claims that Julian and Dante were roles in a contest meant to make Scarlett choose between two suitors, and that Julian’s account of Rosa was part of the act. Julian then admits that his feelings for Scarlett were real, crossing the rules of his performance. The supposed Legend stabs him, and Scarlett watches him die. Hoping the winner’s wish might bring him back, she continues looking for Tella. An invitation to her sister’s funeral makes that search seem even more urgent, but when Scarlett finds Tella alive in a tower, the invitation’s wording has changed.

The last night pushes the illusion and its consequences together. Tella steps from a balcony to protect Scarlett from their father and Count d’Arcy, and Scarlett believes she has lost her sister. Instead of accepting the marriage or returning to her old fear, she confronts Governor Dragna with what she knows about his crimes. Having found Tella, Scarlett realizes she has won, but the supposed Legend refuses to grant her wish. She tries unsuccessfully to restore Tella with drops of her own blood. The following day, Scarlett finds Tella’s letter to Legend and discovers that Caspar, the man presented as Master Legend, is only an actor playing him. Tella is alive: the leap and its apparent finality were part of a plan she had made with Legend, and Scarlett’s wish brought her back. Tella had trusted Scarlett to love her enough to make that wish.

At the performers’ afterparty, the people Scarlett met in character appear as themselves, and the final conversation with Julian changes the meaning of his apparent betrayal without erasing it. He gives Scarlett his full name, admits that he is Legend’s brother and says that he was not always acting; he also insists his feelings for her are real. Dante, too, returns through the troupe’s magic. Julian explains that performers can revive after death, although their injuries leave scars. Tella has no such protection, so her plan really depended on Scarlett’s wish. The book does not identify the true Master Legend by name, and its epilogue shifts briefly to Tella’s viewpoint: a mysterious “friend” congratulates her on the successful plan and says he will soon collect what she owes. The first Caraval story closes with the sisters free of their father, but with Tella’s private bargain still open.

Book details

Author
Stephanie Garber
Published
2017 (earliest confirmed edition)
Series
Caraval, book 1
Subgenre
Fantasy romance, Fairytale retelling
Primary genre
Romance, Fantasy
Tags
Romantasy
Reading order
Also on this shelf: Legendary (book 2)

Review

Review coming soon

Editor profile

Books editor

Baby Bat

Goodreads and social links will be added soon.

  • Goodreads — link coming soon
  • Social media — link coming soon