V4mp

Explore V4mp

Baby Bat’s library

Find your next route. Get back to playing.

BookRomance
← Back to the romance shelf
Cover of A Discovery of Witches by Deborah Harkness

A Discovery of Witches

Deborah Harkness2011Witch and magicParanormal romanceRomantasy (tag)

Diana Bishop is a historian who has spent years keeping her own magic at arm's length, and a witch by lineage whether she likes it or not.

About

Spoiler notice: Major spoilers follow, including the ending of A Discovery of Witches.

Diana Bishop has built a life around historical research, careful reasoning and distance from the magic inherited through her family. At Oxford’s Bodleian Library, where she is studying alchemical manuscripts, she calls up Ashmole 782, a volume that has been missing for centuries. Its strange response unsettles her, but she treats the discovery as a scholarly problem and returns the book to the stacks. That choice does not restore her quiet routine. The manuscript has drawn attention from the hidden society around her: witches, daemons and vampires, each living beside ordinary people under rules meant to keep their existence concealed. Diana’s attempt to remain an observer ends when the archive makes her part of the mystery. The action unfolds over roughly six weeks, from Diana’s first encounter with the book in September to Halloween, giving the early investigation a clear calendar even as magic unsettles her sense of what can be explained.

Matthew Clairmont arrives as both a fellow researcher and a source of danger. He is a vampire and a geneticist, accustomed to approaching questions through evidence, inheritance and the study of living creatures. Ashmole 782 interests him, but so does Diana, whose magical abilities she has spent years refusing to understand. Their encounters move between the Bodleian’s reading rooms and the wider Oxford setting, where other creatures watch Diana and make clear that the manuscript is not an academic curiosity to them. She and Matthew begin to investigate the book’s history together, though neither can make the work emotionally neutral. Their growing attachment complicates every exchange: each is trying to decide what the other wants while the attention around them tightens.

The danger has a political shape as well as a supernatural one. Witches, daemons and vampires are bound by an old covenant overseen by the Congregation, and a relationship between a witch and a vampire violates its rules. Diana and Matthew’s cooperation therefore challenges a system that claims to preserve secrecy and order by policing contact between species. Family loyalties deepen the pressure. Diana’s aunt Sarah and Sarah’s partner Emily want to protect her, while Matthew’s formidable mother, Ysabeau, measures Diana against the histories and injuries of her own family. The book lets these relationships alter the meaning of safety: protection can be an act of care, but it can also become control, and the people trying to help Diana do not always agree about what she should be allowed to choose.

Ashmole 782 connects the novel’s strands of alchemy, history and science. Diana studies old chemical texts by looking for patterns and intelligible methods; Matthew’s work in genetics gives him another language for thinking about inheritance and the differences among creatures. The manuscript’s hidden writing makes interpretation part of the action: reading it requires more than recognizing symbols, because the book is bound up with the history its readers are trying to recover. Diana’s own family history is also incomplete. Her parents died when she was a child, and fear of what happened has shaped her decision to suppress her witchcraft. As questions about the manuscript meet questions about her parents, the research pushes her toward knowledge she would rather keep at a distance. The viewpoint largely follows Diana in first person, then occasionally shifts into third-person chapters centered on Matthew. That change lets the reader see his attention and private calculations while Diana is absent, adding context to the courtship without making the manuscript’s larger mystery disappear.

At Sept-Tours, the de Clermont family’s French estate, Diana encounters the force of Matthew’s family history and the limits of his protection. The witch Satu Järvinen abducts her from the grounds, takes her to a ruined castle and tortures her in an attempt to uncover the secrets of her power. Trapped in an oubliette, Diana experiences a childhood memory of her mother telling her a story about a little witch whose magic was wrapped away for safety. What seemed to be Diana’s refusal to practise witchcraft has another cause: her parents bound her powers to protect her from other witches. The revelation changes what learning magic will mean. She has to understand a protective act performed before she could consent to it, while deciding how much to trust Matthew’s own guarded account of his past. The courtship now involves surviving the consequences of secrets kept by both families.

The danger follows them to Diana’s childhood home, where witches, vampires and daemons begin building an alliance across the divisions enforced by the Congregation. Juliette, a vampire from Matthew’s past, attacks him and leaves him dying. Diana destroys her with fire, then bargains with the goddess and gives Matthew her blood to save him, nearly dying herself. The rescue leaves a promise she cannot yet measure. They decide to seek safety and a teacher for Diana by travelling into the past. Three objects from Matthew’s earlier life will guide them to his English home, Old Lodge, in 1590. Their preparations include practising timewalking and leaving responsibilities with the allies who remain behind. Diana and Matthew do walk back through time before the novel ends; Sarah subsequently receives a message indicating they arrived safely. Their experiences in that earlier world remain ahead, while the people left at the Bishop house face the consequences of their departure.

Book details

Author
Deborah Harkness
First published
2011
Series
All Souls, book 1
Subgenre
Witch and magic, Paranormal romance
Primary genre
Romance, Fantasy
Tags
Romantasy
Reading order
Also on this shelf: Shadow of Night (book 2), The Book of Life (book 3)

Review

Review coming soon

Editor profile

Books editor

Baby Bat

Goodreads and social links will be added soon.

  • Goodreads — link coming soon
  • Social media — link coming soon